War in the Museum: The Historial of the Great War in Péronne and the Military History Museum in Dresden

Nina Parish, Eleanor Rowley, Cristian Cercel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article examines how contemporary war museums represent war and war-making. It looks at and compares the ideas underpinning the permanent exhibitions of two museums – the Historial of the Great War in Péronne (France) and the Military History Museum (MHM) in Dresden (Germany) –, analyzing examples from the exhibitions to illustrate the argument. It also discusses the architecture of these museums and their respective horizontal and vertical configurations. Our analysis demonstrates that the Historial promotes an anti-war message in the name of European reconciliation whilst the narrative put forward by the MHM allows for the possibility of war. On a theoretical level, it shows that a cosmopolitan mode of remembering, although consensus-oriented, can create surprisingly different political positions whilst suggesting that an agonistic turn in representing war and war-making in the museum, with an onus on multiple, even conflicting, perspectives, can help respond to contemporary challenges related to difficult history.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)194-214
Number of pages21
JournalJournal of War and Culture Studies
Volume12
Issue number2
Early online date1 Mar 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 3 Apr 2019

Keywords

  • Historial of the Great War
  • Military History Museum in Dresden
  • agonistic memory
  • cosmopolitan memory
  • cultural turn
  • war museums

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anthropology
  • History
  • Political Science and International Relations

Cite this

War in the Museum: The Historial of the Great War in Péronne and the Military History Museum in Dresden. / Parish, Nina; Rowley, Eleanor; Cercel, Cristian.

In: Journal of War and Culture Studies, Vol. 12, No. 2, 03.04.2019, p. 194-214.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{16822c677e034e3c8b8467af240250c0,
title = "War in the Museum: The Historial of the Great War in P{\'e}ronne and the Military History Museum in Dresden",
abstract = "This article examines how contemporary war museums represent war and war-making. It looks at and compares the ideas underpinning the permanent exhibitions of two museums – the Historial of the Great War in P{\'e}ronne (France) and the Military History Museum (MHM) in Dresden (Germany) –, analyzing examples from the exhibitions to illustrate the argument. It also discusses the architecture of these museums and their respective horizontal and vertical configurations. Our analysis demonstrates that the Historial promotes an anti-war message in the name of European reconciliation whilst the narrative put forward by the MHM allows for the possibility of war. On a theoretical level, it shows that a cosmopolitan mode of remembering, although consensus-oriented, can create surprisingly different political positions whilst suggesting that an agonistic turn in representing war and war-making in the museum, with an onus on multiple, even conflicting, perspectives, can help respond to contemporary challenges related to difficult history.",
keywords = "Historial of the Great War, Military History Museum in Dresden, agonistic memory, cosmopolitan memory, cultural turn, war museums",
author = "Nina Parish and Eleanor Rowley and Cristian Cercel",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "3",
doi = "10.1080/17526272.2019.1580846",
language = "English",
volume = "12",
pages = "194--214",
journal = "Journal of War and Culture Studies",
issn = "1752-6272",
publisher = "Maney Publishing",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - War in the Museum: The Historial of the Great War in Péronne and the Military History Museum in Dresden

AU - Parish, Nina

AU - Rowley, Eleanor

AU - Cercel, Cristian

PY - 2019/4/3

Y1 - 2019/4/3

N2 - This article examines how contemporary war museums represent war and war-making. It looks at and compares the ideas underpinning the permanent exhibitions of two museums – the Historial of the Great War in Péronne (France) and the Military History Museum (MHM) in Dresden (Germany) –, analyzing examples from the exhibitions to illustrate the argument. It also discusses the architecture of these museums and their respective horizontal and vertical configurations. Our analysis demonstrates that the Historial promotes an anti-war message in the name of European reconciliation whilst the narrative put forward by the MHM allows for the possibility of war. On a theoretical level, it shows that a cosmopolitan mode of remembering, although consensus-oriented, can create surprisingly different political positions whilst suggesting that an agonistic turn in representing war and war-making in the museum, with an onus on multiple, even conflicting, perspectives, can help respond to contemporary challenges related to difficult history.

AB - This article examines how contemporary war museums represent war and war-making. It looks at and compares the ideas underpinning the permanent exhibitions of two museums – the Historial of the Great War in Péronne (France) and the Military History Museum (MHM) in Dresden (Germany) –, analyzing examples from the exhibitions to illustrate the argument. It also discusses the architecture of these museums and their respective horizontal and vertical configurations. Our analysis demonstrates that the Historial promotes an anti-war message in the name of European reconciliation whilst the narrative put forward by the MHM allows for the possibility of war. On a theoretical level, it shows that a cosmopolitan mode of remembering, although consensus-oriented, can create surprisingly different political positions whilst suggesting that an agonistic turn in representing war and war-making in the museum, with an onus on multiple, even conflicting, perspectives, can help respond to contemporary challenges related to difficult history.

KW - Historial of the Great War

KW - Military History Museum in Dresden

KW - agonistic memory

KW - cosmopolitan memory

KW - cultural turn

KW - war museums

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85062471538&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/17526272.2019.1580846

DO - 10.1080/17526272.2019.1580846

M3 - Article

VL - 12

SP - 194

EP - 214

JO - Journal of War and Culture Studies

JF - Journal of War and Culture Studies

SN - 1752-6272

IS - 2

ER -