The measurement of approximate number system acuity across the lifespan is compromised by congruency effects

Jade Norris, Sarah Clayton, Camilla Gilmore, Matthew Inglis, Julie Castronovo

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent studies have highlighted the influence of visual cues such as dot size and cumulative surface area on the measurement of the approximate number system (ANS). Previous studies assessing ANS acuity in ageing have all applied stimuli generated by the Panamath protocol, which does not control nor measure the influence of convex hull. Crucially, convex hull has recently been identified as an influential visual cue present in dot arrays, with its impact on older adults’ ANS acuity yet to be investigated. The current study therefore investigated the manipulation of convex hull by the Panamath protocol, and its effect on the measurement of ANS acuity in younger and older participants. First, analyses of the stimuli generated by Panamath revealed a confound between numerosity ratio and convex hull ratio. Second, although older adults were somewhat less accurate than younger adults on convex hull incongruent trials, ANS acuity was broadly similar between the groups. These findings have implications for the valid measurement of ANS acuity across all ages, and suggest that the Panamath protocol produces stimuli that do not adequately control for the influence of convex hull on numerosity discrimination.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1037-1046
Number of pages10
JournalQuarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology
Volume72
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2018

Cite this

The measurement of approximate number system acuity across the lifespan is compromised by congruency effects. / Norris, Jade; Clayton, Sarah; Gilmore, Camilla; Inglis, Matthew; Castronovo, Julie.

In: Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, Vol. 72, No. 5, 01.05.2018, p. 1037-1046.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Norris, Jade ; Clayton, Sarah ; Gilmore, Camilla ; Inglis, Matthew ; Castronovo, Julie. / The measurement of approximate number system acuity across the lifespan is compromised by congruency effects. In: Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology. 2018 ; Vol. 72, No. 5. pp. 1037-1046.
@article{73f0a8c60a194b509874c70cb99d6eaf,
title = "The measurement of approximate number system acuity across the lifespan is compromised by congruency effects",
abstract = "Recent studies have highlighted the influence of visual cues such as dot size and cumulative surface area on the measurement of the approximate number system (ANS). Previous studies assessing ANS acuity in ageing have all applied stimuli generated by the Panamath protocol, which does not control nor measure the influence of convex hull. Crucially, convex hull has recently been identified as an influential visual cue present in dot arrays, with its impact on older adults’ ANS acuity yet to be investigated. The current study therefore investigated the manipulation of convex hull by the Panamath protocol, and its effect on the measurement of ANS acuity in younger and older participants. First, analyses of the stimuli generated by Panamath revealed a confound between numerosity ratio and convex hull ratio. Second, although older adults were somewhat less accurate than younger adults on convex hull incongruent trials, ANS acuity was broadly similar between the groups. These findings have implications for the valid measurement of ANS acuity across all ages, and suggest that the Panamath protocol produces stimuli that do not adequately control for the influence of convex hull on numerosity discrimination.",
author = "Jade Norris and Sarah Clayton and Camilla Gilmore and Matthew Inglis and Julie Castronovo",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/1747021818779020",
language = "English",
volume = "72",
pages = "1037--1046",
journal = "Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology",
issn = "1747-0218",
publisher = "Psychology Press Ltd",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The measurement of approximate number system acuity across the lifespan is compromised by congruency effects

AU - Norris, Jade

AU - Clayton, Sarah

AU - Gilmore, Camilla

AU - Inglis, Matthew

AU - Castronovo, Julie

PY - 2018/5/1

Y1 - 2018/5/1

N2 - Recent studies have highlighted the influence of visual cues such as dot size and cumulative surface area on the measurement of the approximate number system (ANS). Previous studies assessing ANS acuity in ageing have all applied stimuli generated by the Panamath protocol, which does not control nor measure the influence of convex hull. Crucially, convex hull has recently been identified as an influential visual cue present in dot arrays, with its impact on older adults’ ANS acuity yet to be investigated. The current study therefore investigated the manipulation of convex hull by the Panamath protocol, and its effect on the measurement of ANS acuity in younger and older participants. First, analyses of the stimuli generated by Panamath revealed a confound between numerosity ratio and convex hull ratio. Second, although older adults were somewhat less accurate than younger adults on convex hull incongruent trials, ANS acuity was broadly similar between the groups. These findings have implications for the valid measurement of ANS acuity across all ages, and suggest that the Panamath protocol produces stimuli that do not adequately control for the influence of convex hull on numerosity discrimination.

AB - Recent studies have highlighted the influence of visual cues such as dot size and cumulative surface area on the measurement of the approximate number system (ANS). Previous studies assessing ANS acuity in ageing have all applied stimuli generated by the Panamath protocol, which does not control nor measure the influence of convex hull. Crucially, convex hull has recently been identified as an influential visual cue present in dot arrays, with its impact on older adults’ ANS acuity yet to be investigated. The current study therefore investigated the manipulation of convex hull by the Panamath protocol, and its effect on the measurement of ANS acuity in younger and older participants. First, analyses of the stimuli generated by Panamath revealed a confound between numerosity ratio and convex hull ratio. Second, although older adults were somewhat less accurate than younger adults on convex hull incongruent trials, ANS acuity was broadly similar between the groups. These findings have implications for the valid measurement of ANS acuity across all ages, and suggest that the Panamath protocol produces stimuli that do not adequately control for the influence of convex hull on numerosity discrimination.

U2 - 10.1177/1747021818779020

DO - 10.1177/1747021818779020

M3 - Article

VL - 72

SP - 1037

EP - 1046

JO - Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology

JF - Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology

SN - 1747-0218

IS - 5

ER -