The effect of bearing congruency, thickness and alignment on the stresses in unicompartmental knee replacements

D. J. Simpson, H. Gray, D. D'Lima, D. W. Murray, H. S. Gill

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

43 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Unicompartmental knee replacement offers an effective treatment for patients with single compartment knee disease and is becoming an increasingly popular alternative to total knee replacement. An important cause of failure in a unicompartmental knee replacement implant is polyethylene wear. Significant contributory factors to the amount of polyethylene wear are contact stress, bearing alignment, congruency and thickness. METHODS: Four different unicompartmental knee replacement implant designs (Fully-Congruent; Partially-Congruent; Non-Congruent-metal-backed; Non-Congruent-all-polyethylene) were inserted into a validated finite element model of a proximal tibia. The effect that bearing congruency, alignment and thickness had on the polyethylene stresses during a simulated step-up activity for each design was investigated. Additionally, contact pressures were compared to those calculated from Hertz elastic theory. FINDINGS: Only the Fully-Congruent bearing experienced peak von Mises and contact stresses below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene during the step-up activity. The highest polyethylene contact stresses were observed for the Partially-Congruent and Non-Congruent-metal-backed designs, which experienced approximately three times the polyethylene lower fatigue limit. Increasing the bearing thickness from 3.5mm to 8.5mm of the Non-Congruent design decreased the contact stresses in the bearing; however they did not fall below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene. Good agreement between finite element and Hertz contact pressures was found. INTERPRETATION: Fully congruent unicompartmental knee replacement bearings can be markedly thinner without approaching the material failure limit, have a greater potential to preserve bone stock and are less likely to fail mechanically.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1148-1157
Number of pages10
JournalClinical Biomechanics
Volume23
Issue number9
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2008

Fingerprint

Knee Replacement Arthroplasties
Polyethylene
Fatigue
Metals
Pressure
Tibia
Knee
Bone and Bones

Cite this

The effect of bearing congruency, thickness and alignment on the stresses in unicompartmental knee replacements. / Simpson, D. J.; Gray, H.; D'Lima, D.; Murray, D. W.; Gill, H. S.

In: Clinical Biomechanics, Vol. 23, No. 9, 11.2008, p. 1148-1157.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Simpson, D. J. ; Gray, H. ; D'Lima, D. ; Murray, D. W. ; Gill, H. S. / The effect of bearing congruency, thickness and alignment on the stresses in unicompartmental knee replacements. In: Clinical Biomechanics. 2008 ; Vol. 23, No. 9. pp. 1148-1157.
@article{95292c0f80334a748b8a15131fbbac7e,
title = "The effect of bearing congruency, thickness and alignment on the stresses in unicompartmental knee replacements",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Unicompartmental knee replacement offers an effective treatment for patients with single compartment knee disease and is becoming an increasingly popular alternative to total knee replacement. An important cause of failure in a unicompartmental knee replacement implant is polyethylene wear. Significant contributory factors to the amount of polyethylene wear are contact stress, bearing alignment, congruency and thickness. METHODS: Four different unicompartmental knee replacement implant designs (Fully-Congruent; Partially-Congruent; Non-Congruent-metal-backed; Non-Congruent-all-polyethylene) were inserted into a validated finite element model of a proximal tibia. The effect that bearing congruency, alignment and thickness had on the polyethylene stresses during a simulated step-up activity for each design was investigated. Additionally, contact pressures were compared to those calculated from Hertz elastic theory. FINDINGS: Only the Fully-Congruent bearing experienced peak von Mises and contact stresses below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene during the step-up activity. The highest polyethylene contact stresses were observed for the Partially-Congruent and Non-Congruent-metal-backed designs, which experienced approximately three times the polyethylene lower fatigue limit. Increasing the bearing thickness from 3.5mm to 8.5mm of the Non-Congruent design decreased the contact stresses in the bearing; however they did not fall below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene. Good agreement between finite element and Hertz contact pressures was found. INTERPRETATION: Fully congruent unicompartmental knee replacement bearings can be markedly thinner without approaching the material failure limit, have a greater potential to preserve bone stock and are less likely to fail mechanically.",
author = "Simpson, {D. J.} and H. Gray and D. D'Lima and Murray, {D. W.} and Gill, {H. S.}",
year = "2008",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.001",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "1148--1157",
journal = "Clinical Biomechanics",
issn = "0268-0033",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The effect of bearing congruency, thickness and alignment on the stresses in unicompartmental knee replacements

AU - Simpson, D. J.

AU - Gray, H.

AU - D'Lima, D.

AU - Murray, D. W.

AU - Gill, H. S.

PY - 2008/11

Y1 - 2008/11

N2 - BACKGROUND: Unicompartmental knee replacement offers an effective treatment for patients with single compartment knee disease and is becoming an increasingly popular alternative to total knee replacement. An important cause of failure in a unicompartmental knee replacement implant is polyethylene wear. Significant contributory factors to the amount of polyethylene wear are contact stress, bearing alignment, congruency and thickness. METHODS: Four different unicompartmental knee replacement implant designs (Fully-Congruent; Partially-Congruent; Non-Congruent-metal-backed; Non-Congruent-all-polyethylene) were inserted into a validated finite element model of a proximal tibia. The effect that bearing congruency, alignment and thickness had on the polyethylene stresses during a simulated step-up activity for each design was investigated. Additionally, contact pressures were compared to those calculated from Hertz elastic theory. FINDINGS: Only the Fully-Congruent bearing experienced peak von Mises and contact stresses below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene during the step-up activity. The highest polyethylene contact stresses were observed for the Partially-Congruent and Non-Congruent-metal-backed designs, which experienced approximately three times the polyethylene lower fatigue limit. Increasing the bearing thickness from 3.5mm to 8.5mm of the Non-Congruent design decreased the contact stresses in the bearing; however they did not fall below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene. Good agreement between finite element and Hertz contact pressures was found. INTERPRETATION: Fully congruent unicompartmental knee replacement bearings can be markedly thinner without approaching the material failure limit, have a greater potential to preserve bone stock and are less likely to fail mechanically.

AB - BACKGROUND: Unicompartmental knee replacement offers an effective treatment for patients with single compartment knee disease and is becoming an increasingly popular alternative to total knee replacement. An important cause of failure in a unicompartmental knee replacement implant is polyethylene wear. Significant contributory factors to the amount of polyethylene wear are contact stress, bearing alignment, congruency and thickness. METHODS: Four different unicompartmental knee replacement implant designs (Fully-Congruent; Partially-Congruent; Non-Congruent-metal-backed; Non-Congruent-all-polyethylene) were inserted into a validated finite element model of a proximal tibia. The effect that bearing congruency, alignment and thickness had on the polyethylene stresses during a simulated step-up activity for each design was investigated. Additionally, contact pressures were compared to those calculated from Hertz elastic theory. FINDINGS: Only the Fully-Congruent bearing experienced peak von Mises and contact stresses below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene during the step-up activity. The highest polyethylene contact stresses were observed for the Partially-Congruent and Non-Congruent-metal-backed designs, which experienced approximately three times the polyethylene lower fatigue limit. Increasing the bearing thickness from 3.5mm to 8.5mm of the Non-Congruent design decreased the contact stresses in the bearing; however they did not fall below the lower fatigue limit for polyethylene. Good agreement between finite element and Hertz contact pressures was found. INTERPRETATION: Fully congruent unicompartmental knee replacement bearings can be markedly thinner without approaching the material failure limit, have a greater potential to preserve bone stock and are less likely to fail mechanically.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=53449092552&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt=Citation&list_uids=18639960

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.001

U2 - 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.001

DO - 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.001

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 1148

EP - 1157

JO - Clinical Biomechanics

JF - Clinical Biomechanics

SN - 0268-0033

IS - 9

ER -