The dream of dignified work

On good and bad utopias

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)
108 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

To what extents are recent labour upsurges defensive struggles? I use the experience of the Argentinean Movement of Unemployed Workers (also called the Piquetero movement) as my empirical basis for discussing the contribution of unemployed workers to the current reshaping of the labour question. I offer an alternative interpretation of the Piquetero experience of resistance that emphasises their critique and alternative visions, and the transformations and alternatives that the movement put forward at a time when ‘labour’ was said to be defeated. The struggles of the unemployed workers in Argentina during the 1990s should not be classified as a defensive struggle for inclusion in the labour market or as a demand for social security (although these demands were significant in the Piqueteros’ agenda), but rather as advancing significant changes at identity/organizational, socioeconomic and political institutional levels — changes that deserve special attention in terms of their significance for the reshaping of the labour question in the twenty-first century. The Piquetero utopia of dignified work does not rely on state policy such as Universal Income Support. Rather, the state and policy are mediations of their autonomous struggle for the prefigurations of a better society.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1037-1058
Number of pages22
JournalDevelopment and Change
Volume45
Issue number5
Early online date27 Aug 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 17 Sep 2014

Fingerprint

utopia
labor
worker
social security
twenty first century
labor market
Argentina
twenty-first century
mediation
experience
inclusion
income
interpretation
demand
policy

Keywords

  • movement of unemployed workers
  • Argentina
  • the labour question
  • debate
  • universal income support
  • community projects
  • policy
  • unemployment
  • dignity
  • politics
  • real subsumption
  • utopia
  • territories of hope

Cite this

The dream of dignified work : On good and bad utopias. / Dinerstein, Ana Cecilia.

In: Development and Change, Vol. 45, No. 5, 17.09.2014, p. 1037-1058.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{2cb795aa2b6443fd945ca44f6cb67dba,
title = "The dream of dignified work: On good and bad utopias",
abstract = "To what extents are recent labour upsurges defensive struggles? I use the experience of the Argentinean Movement of Unemployed Workers (also called the Piquetero movement) as my empirical basis for discussing the contribution of unemployed workers to the current reshaping of the labour question. I offer an alternative interpretation of the Piquetero experience of resistance that emphasises their critique and alternative visions, and the transformations and alternatives that the movement put forward at a time when ‘labour’ was said to be defeated. The struggles of the unemployed workers in Argentina during the 1990s should not be classified as a defensive struggle for inclusion in the labour market or as a demand for social security (although these demands were significant in the Piqueteros’ agenda), but rather as advancing significant changes at identity/organizational, socioeconomic and political institutional levels — changes that deserve special attention in terms of their significance for the reshaping of the labour question in the twenty-first century. The Piquetero utopia of dignified work does not rely on state policy such as Universal Income Support. Rather, the state and policy are mediations of their autonomous struggle for the prefigurations of a better society.",
keywords = "movement of unemployed workers, Argentina , the labour question, debate, universal income support , community projects, policy, unemployment, dignity, politics, real subsumption, utopia, territories of hope",
author = "Dinerstein, {Ana Cecilia}",
note = "Ana C. Dinerstein is an senior lecturer (associate professor) in sociology at the University of Bath. She published numerous articles on labour subjectivity, autonomous movements and Argentine and Latin American politics. She is coeditor of The Labour Debate (2002). Her book The politics of Autonomy in Latin America: The art of organising hope is forthcoming (Palgrave Macmillan, October 2014) Mail to: A.C.Dinerstein@bath.ac.uk",
year = "2014",
month = "9",
day = "17",
doi = "10.1111/dech.12118",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "1037--1058",
journal = "Development and Change",
issn = "0012-155X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The dream of dignified work

T2 - On good and bad utopias

AU - Dinerstein, Ana Cecilia

N1 - Ana C. Dinerstein is an senior lecturer (associate professor) in sociology at the University of Bath. She published numerous articles on labour subjectivity, autonomous movements and Argentine and Latin American politics. She is coeditor of The Labour Debate (2002). Her book The politics of Autonomy in Latin America: The art of organising hope is forthcoming (Palgrave Macmillan, October 2014) Mail to: A.C.Dinerstein@bath.ac.uk

PY - 2014/9/17

Y1 - 2014/9/17

N2 - To what extents are recent labour upsurges defensive struggles? I use the experience of the Argentinean Movement of Unemployed Workers (also called the Piquetero movement) as my empirical basis for discussing the contribution of unemployed workers to the current reshaping of the labour question. I offer an alternative interpretation of the Piquetero experience of resistance that emphasises their critique and alternative visions, and the transformations and alternatives that the movement put forward at a time when ‘labour’ was said to be defeated. The struggles of the unemployed workers in Argentina during the 1990s should not be classified as a defensive struggle for inclusion in the labour market or as a demand for social security (although these demands were significant in the Piqueteros’ agenda), but rather as advancing significant changes at identity/organizational, socioeconomic and political institutional levels — changes that deserve special attention in terms of their significance for the reshaping of the labour question in the twenty-first century. The Piquetero utopia of dignified work does not rely on state policy such as Universal Income Support. Rather, the state and policy are mediations of their autonomous struggle for the prefigurations of a better society.

AB - To what extents are recent labour upsurges defensive struggles? I use the experience of the Argentinean Movement of Unemployed Workers (also called the Piquetero movement) as my empirical basis for discussing the contribution of unemployed workers to the current reshaping of the labour question. I offer an alternative interpretation of the Piquetero experience of resistance that emphasises their critique and alternative visions, and the transformations and alternatives that the movement put forward at a time when ‘labour’ was said to be defeated. The struggles of the unemployed workers in Argentina during the 1990s should not be classified as a defensive struggle for inclusion in the labour market or as a demand for social security (although these demands were significant in the Piqueteros’ agenda), but rather as advancing significant changes at identity/organizational, socioeconomic and political institutional levels — changes that deserve special attention in terms of their significance for the reshaping of the labour question in the twenty-first century. The Piquetero utopia of dignified work does not rely on state policy such as Universal Income Support. Rather, the state and policy are mediations of their autonomous struggle for the prefigurations of a better society.

KW - movement of unemployed workers

KW - Argentina

KW - the labour question

KW - debate

KW - universal income support

KW - community projects

KW - policy

KW - unemployment

KW - dignity

KW - politics

KW - real subsumption

KW - utopia

KW - territories of hope

U2 - 10.1111/dech.12118

DO - 10.1111/dech.12118

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 1037

EP - 1058

JO - Development and Change

JF - Development and Change

SN - 0012-155X

IS - 5

ER -