Scenario analysis to support decision making in addressing wicked problems: pitfalls and potential

George Wright, George Cairns, Frances O'Brien, Paul Goodwin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper provides a review and evaluation of the use of scenario methods from the Intuitive Logics (IL) school to address so-called ‘wicked problems’. Scenario planning has been widely advocated by its practitioners and its popularity has increased in the practice arena since the Millennium. However, some academics have described the technique as an ‘art’ that lacks theoretical and methodological rigour. Over recent years, academics have responded to this critique, drawing on both empirical and conceptual studies. This has led to a multiplicity of augmented IL scenario methods. Here, we review these developments and compare them to soft OR methods as a means of tackling wicked problems, drawing, in particular, on Churchman’s moral imperative that we must address the whole problem, not merely ‘carve off’ one part. We conclude that IL scenario planning can be a useful tool in the OR practitioner’s tool kit and that it can complement many of the established soft OR methods.
LanguageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of Operational Research
Early online date29 Aug 2018
StatusE-pub ahead of print - 29 Aug 2018

Fingerprint

Scenario Analysis
Decision making
Decision Making
Planning
Intuitive
Scenarios
Logic
Multiplicity
Complement
Wicked problems
Scenario analysis
Evaluation
Soft OR
Scenario planning
Scenario method
Review
Drawing

Keywords

  • scenarios.
  • intuitive logics
  • soft OR methods
  • wicked problems
  • decision making

Cite this

Scenario analysis to support decision making in addressing wicked problems: pitfalls and potential. / Wright, George; Cairns, George; O'Brien, Frances; Goodwin, Paul.

In: European Journal of Operational Research, 29.08.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f22512bfdba44f5cb956445d2e76b369,
title = "Scenario analysis to support decision making in addressing wicked problems: pitfalls and potential",
abstract = "This paper provides a review and evaluation of the use of scenario methods from the Intuitive Logics (IL) school to address so-called ‘wicked problems’. Scenario planning has been widely advocated by its practitioners and its popularity has increased in the practice arena since the Millennium. However, some academics have described the technique as an ‘art’ that lacks theoretical and methodological rigour. Over recent years, academics have responded to this critique, drawing on both empirical and conceptual studies. This has led to a multiplicity of augmented IL scenario methods. Here, we review these developments and compare them to soft OR methods as a means of tackling wicked problems, drawing, in particular, on Churchman’s moral imperative that we must address the whole problem, not merely ‘carve off’ one part. We conclude that IL scenario planning can be a useful tool in the OR practitioner’s tool kit and that it can complement many of the established soft OR methods.",
keywords = "scenarios., intuitive logics, soft OR methods, wicked problems, decision making",
author = "George Wright and George Cairns and Frances O'Brien and Paul Goodwin",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "29",
language = "English",
journal = "European Journal of Operational Research",
issn = "0377-2217",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Scenario analysis to support decision making in addressing wicked problems: pitfalls and potential

AU - Wright,George

AU - Cairns,George

AU - O'Brien,Frances

AU - Goodwin,Paul

PY - 2018/8/29

Y1 - 2018/8/29

N2 - This paper provides a review and evaluation of the use of scenario methods from the Intuitive Logics (IL) school to address so-called ‘wicked problems’. Scenario planning has been widely advocated by its practitioners and its popularity has increased in the practice arena since the Millennium. However, some academics have described the technique as an ‘art’ that lacks theoretical and methodological rigour. Over recent years, academics have responded to this critique, drawing on both empirical and conceptual studies. This has led to a multiplicity of augmented IL scenario methods. Here, we review these developments and compare them to soft OR methods as a means of tackling wicked problems, drawing, in particular, on Churchman’s moral imperative that we must address the whole problem, not merely ‘carve off’ one part. We conclude that IL scenario planning can be a useful tool in the OR practitioner’s tool kit and that it can complement many of the established soft OR methods.

AB - This paper provides a review and evaluation of the use of scenario methods from the Intuitive Logics (IL) school to address so-called ‘wicked problems’. Scenario planning has been widely advocated by its practitioners and its popularity has increased in the practice arena since the Millennium. However, some academics have described the technique as an ‘art’ that lacks theoretical and methodological rigour. Over recent years, academics have responded to this critique, drawing on both empirical and conceptual studies. This has led to a multiplicity of augmented IL scenario methods. Here, we review these developments and compare them to soft OR methods as a means of tackling wicked problems, drawing, in particular, on Churchman’s moral imperative that we must address the whole problem, not merely ‘carve off’ one part. We conclude that IL scenario planning can be a useful tool in the OR practitioner’s tool kit and that it can complement many of the established soft OR methods.

KW - scenarios.

KW - intuitive logics

KW - soft OR methods

KW - wicked problems

KW - decision making

M3 - Article

JO - European Journal of Operational Research

T2 - European Journal of Operational Research

JF - European Journal of Operational Research

SN - 0377-2217

ER -