Rocking of a bell tower - investigation by non-contact video measurement

Paul McCombie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Church bells are rung in many historic towers, principally in United Kingdom, in a way which enables precise control of timing, and changes in the sequences of the bells – this is known as change ringing. The bells are heavy, many towers containing bells which weigh over a tonne. They are rung by swinging them on an axle through angles approaching 360o, applying substantial forces to the towers. These forces may cause structural damage, and movements of the tower that discomfort the ringers and can make ringing difficult or even dangerous. The movements of towers caused by ringing therefore concern both the ringers themselves, and the architects, engineers and authorities responsible for the historic buildings that house the bells. Movements are usually assumed to be caused by flexing of the bell towers. In this study video recording and imaging software has been used to show that a short tower moves by a combination of rocking on its foundations and bending of the masonry, associated with significantly different natural frequencies. It is shown that minor changes in the speed of the ringing can result in a forcing that works with or against these natural frequencies; the fundamental period of bending is much shorter than the fundamental period of the force from a bell, but the period of rocking is much longer. The significance of this longer period movement in short towers has not been previously recognised, as it has not been detected by the accelerometers normally used in investigations of tower movement. This investigation therefore advances understanding of bell tower movements, but also demonstrates the capability of the video recording and image processing used in the investigation.
Original languageEnglish
Article numberENGSTRUCT_2018_1280
Pages (from-to)271-280
Number of pages10
JournalEngineering Structures
Volume193
Early online date31 May 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Aug 2019

Fingerprint

Towers
Video recording
Natural frequencies
Religious buildings
Axles
Accelerometers
Image processing
Imaging techniques
Engineers

Keywords

  • Bell tower; dynamic behaviour; monitoring; foundation response; rocking

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Building and Construction

Cite this

Rocking of a bell tower - investigation by non-contact video measurement. / McCombie, Paul.

In: Engineering Structures, Vol. 193, ENGSTRUCT_2018_1280, 15.08.2019, p. 271-280.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1ad28d9906f54ac3a29bbba8af5f26c5,
title = "Rocking of a bell tower - investigation by non-contact video measurement",
abstract = "Church bells are rung in many historic towers, principally in United Kingdom, in a way which enables precise control of timing, and changes in the sequences of the bells – this is known as change ringing. The bells are heavy, many towers containing bells which weigh over a tonne. They are rung by swinging them on an axle through angles approaching 360o, applying substantial forces to the towers. These forces may cause structural damage, and movements of the tower that discomfort the ringers and can make ringing difficult or even dangerous. The movements of towers caused by ringing therefore concern both the ringers themselves, and the architects, engineers and authorities responsible for the historic buildings that house the bells. Movements are usually assumed to be caused by flexing of the bell towers. In this study video recording and imaging software has been used to show that a short tower moves by a combination of rocking on its foundations and bending of the masonry, associated with significantly different natural frequencies. It is shown that minor changes in the speed of the ringing can result in a forcing that works with or against these natural frequencies; the fundamental period of bending is much shorter than the fundamental period of the force from a bell, but the period of rocking is much longer. The significance of this longer period movement in short towers has not been previously recognised, as it has not been detected by the accelerometers normally used in investigations of tower movement. This investigation therefore advances understanding of bell tower movements, but also demonstrates the capability of the video recording and image processing used in the investigation.",
keywords = "Bell tower; dynamic behaviour; monitoring; foundation response; rocking",
author = "Paul McCombie",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.engstruct.2018.07.104",
language = "English",
volume = "193",
pages = "271--280",
journal = "Engineering Structures",
issn = "0141-0296",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rocking of a bell tower - investigation by non-contact video measurement

AU - McCombie, Paul

PY - 2019/8/15

Y1 - 2019/8/15

N2 - Church bells are rung in many historic towers, principally in United Kingdom, in a way which enables precise control of timing, and changes in the sequences of the bells – this is known as change ringing. The bells are heavy, many towers containing bells which weigh over a tonne. They are rung by swinging them on an axle through angles approaching 360o, applying substantial forces to the towers. These forces may cause structural damage, and movements of the tower that discomfort the ringers and can make ringing difficult or even dangerous. The movements of towers caused by ringing therefore concern both the ringers themselves, and the architects, engineers and authorities responsible for the historic buildings that house the bells. Movements are usually assumed to be caused by flexing of the bell towers. In this study video recording and imaging software has been used to show that a short tower moves by a combination of rocking on its foundations and bending of the masonry, associated with significantly different natural frequencies. It is shown that minor changes in the speed of the ringing can result in a forcing that works with or against these natural frequencies; the fundamental period of bending is much shorter than the fundamental period of the force from a bell, but the period of rocking is much longer. The significance of this longer period movement in short towers has not been previously recognised, as it has not been detected by the accelerometers normally used in investigations of tower movement. This investigation therefore advances understanding of bell tower movements, but also demonstrates the capability of the video recording and image processing used in the investigation.

AB - Church bells are rung in many historic towers, principally in United Kingdom, in a way which enables precise control of timing, and changes in the sequences of the bells – this is known as change ringing. The bells are heavy, many towers containing bells which weigh over a tonne. They are rung by swinging them on an axle through angles approaching 360o, applying substantial forces to the towers. These forces may cause structural damage, and movements of the tower that discomfort the ringers and can make ringing difficult or even dangerous. The movements of towers caused by ringing therefore concern both the ringers themselves, and the architects, engineers and authorities responsible for the historic buildings that house the bells. Movements are usually assumed to be caused by flexing of the bell towers. In this study video recording and imaging software has been used to show that a short tower moves by a combination of rocking on its foundations and bending of the masonry, associated with significantly different natural frequencies. It is shown that minor changes in the speed of the ringing can result in a forcing that works with or against these natural frequencies; the fundamental period of bending is much shorter than the fundamental period of the force from a bell, but the period of rocking is much longer. The significance of this longer period movement in short towers has not been previously recognised, as it has not been detected by the accelerometers normally used in investigations of tower movement. This investigation therefore advances understanding of bell tower movements, but also demonstrates the capability of the video recording and image processing used in the investigation.

KW - Bell tower; dynamic behaviour; monitoring; foundation response; rocking

U2 - 10.1016/j.engstruct.2018.07.104

DO - 10.1016/j.engstruct.2018.07.104

M3 - Article

VL - 193

SP - 271

EP - 280

JO - Engineering Structures

JF - Engineering Structures

SN - 0141-0296

M1 - ENGSTRUCT_2018_1280

ER -