Relative Age and Maturation Selection Biases in Academy Football

Megan Hill, Sam Scott, Robert M Malina, Darragh McGee, Sean Cumming

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This study examined the simultaneous effects of relative age and biological maturity status upon player selection in an English professional soccer academy. A total of 202 players from the U9 to U16 age groups, over an eight-year period (total of 566 observations), had their relative age (birth quarter) and biological maturity (categorised as late, on-time or early maturing based upon the Khamis-Roche method of percentage of predicted adult height at time of observation) recorded. Players born in the first birth quarter of the year (54.8%) were over-represented across all age groups. A selection bias towards players advanced in maturity status for chronological age emerged in U12 players and increased with age; 0% of players in the U15 and U16 age group were categorised as late maturing. A clear maturity selection bias for early maturing players was, however, only apparent when the least conservative criterion for estimating maturity status was applied (53.8% early and 1.9% late maturing in the U16 age group). Professional football academies need to recognise relative age and maturation as independent constructs that exist and operate independently. Thus, separate strategies should perhaps be designed to address the respective selection biases, to better identify, retain and develop players.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-10
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Sports Sciences
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Jul 2019

Keywords

  • soccer
  • puberty
  • talent identification
  • development
  • percentage adult height

Cite this

Relative Age and Maturation Selection Biases in Academy Football. / Hill, Megan; Scott, Sam; Malina, Robert M; McGee, Darragh; Cumming, Sean.

In: Journal of Sports Sciences, 31.07.2019, p. 1-10.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ed225d275df34288b1413d230b6cd415,
title = "Relative Age and Maturation Selection Biases in Academy Football",
abstract = "This study examined the simultaneous effects of relative age and biological maturity status upon player selection in an English professional soccer academy. A total of 202 players from the U9 to U16 age groups, over an eight-year period (total of 566 observations), had their relative age (birth quarter) and biological maturity (categorised as late, on-time or early maturing based upon the Khamis-Roche method of percentage of predicted adult height at time of observation) recorded. Players born in the first birth quarter of the year (54.8{\%}) were over-represented across all age groups. A selection bias towards players advanced in maturity status for chronological age emerged in U12 players and increased with age; 0{\%} of players in the U15 and U16 age group were categorised as late maturing. A clear maturity selection bias for early maturing players was, however, only apparent when the least conservative criterion for estimating maturity status was applied (53.8{\%} early and 1.9{\%} late maturing in the U16 age group). Professional football academies need to recognise relative age and maturation as independent constructs that exist and operate independently. Thus, separate strategies should perhaps be designed to address the respective selection biases, to better identify, retain and develop players.",
keywords = "soccer, puberty, talent identification, development, percentage adult height",
author = "Megan Hill and Sam Scott and Malina, {Robert M} and Darragh McGee and Sean Cumming",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1080/02640414.2019.1649524",
language = "English",
pages = "1--10",
journal = "Journal of Sports Sciences",
issn = "0264-0414",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Relative Age and Maturation Selection Biases in Academy Football

AU - Hill, Megan

AU - Scott, Sam

AU - Malina, Robert M

AU - McGee, Darragh

AU - Cumming, Sean

PY - 2019/7/31

Y1 - 2019/7/31

N2 - This study examined the simultaneous effects of relative age and biological maturity status upon player selection in an English professional soccer academy. A total of 202 players from the U9 to U16 age groups, over an eight-year period (total of 566 observations), had their relative age (birth quarter) and biological maturity (categorised as late, on-time or early maturing based upon the Khamis-Roche method of percentage of predicted adult height at time of observation) recorded. Players born in the first birth quarter of the year (54.8%) were over-represented across all age groups. A selection bias towards players advanced in maturity status for chronological age emerged in U12 players and increased with age; 0% of players in the U15 and U16 age group were categorised as late maturing. A clear maturity selection bias for early maturing players was, however, only apparent when the least conservative criterion for estimating maturity status was applied (53.8% early and 1.9% late maturing in the U16 age group). Professional football academies need to recognise relative age and maturation as independent constructs that exist and operate independently. Thus, separate strategies should perhaps be designed to address the respective selection biases, to better identify, retain and develop players.

AB - This study examined the simultaneous effects of relative age and biological maturity status upon player selection in an English professional soccer academy. A total of 202 players from the U9 to U16 age groups, over an eight-year period (total of 566 observations), had their relative age (birth quarter) and biological maturity (categorised as late, on-time or early maturing based upon the Khamis-Roche method of percentage of predicted adult height at time of observation) recorded. Players born in the first birth quarter of the year (54.8%) were over-represented across all age groups. A selection bias towards players advanced in maturity status for chronological age emerged in U12 players and increased with age; 0% of players in the U15 and U16 age group were categorised as late maturing. A clear maturity selection bias for early maturing players was, however, only apparent when the least conservative criterion for estimating maturity status was applied (53.8% early and 1.9% late maturing in the U16 age group). Professional football academies need to recognise relative age and maturation as independent constructs that exist and operate independently. Thus, separate strategies should perhaps be designed to address the respective selection biases, to better identify, retain and develop players.

KW - soccer

KW - puberty

KW - talent identification

KW - development

KW - percentage adult height

U2 - 10.1080/02640414.2019.1649524

DO - 10.1080/02640414.2019.1649524

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 10

JO - Journal of Sports Sciences

JF - Journal of Sports Sciences

SN - 0264-0414

ER -