Abstract

When individuals learn from what others tell them, the information is subject to transmission error that does not arise in learning from direct experience. Yet evidence shows that humans consistently prefer this apparently more unreliable source of information. We examine the effect this preference has in cases where the information concerns a judgment on others’ behaviour and is used to establish cooperation in a society. We present a spatial model confirming that cooperation can be sustained by gossip containing a high degree of uncertainty. Accuracy alone does not predict the value of information in evolutionary terms; relevance, the impact of information on behavioural outcomes, must also be considered. We then show that once relevance is incorporated as a criterion, second-hand information can no longer be discounted on the basis of its poor fidelity alone. Finally we show that the relative importance of accuracy and relevance depends on factors of life history and demography.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1-25
Number of pages25
JournalInteraction Studies
Volume17
Issue number1
Early online date26 Sep 2016
DOIs
StatusPublished - Oct 2016

Fingerprint

collective memory
Data storage equipment
demography
information sources
source of information
hands
uncertainty
learning
life history
Uncertainty
Gossip
Cultural Memory
evidence
experience

Cite this

On the reliability of unreliable information : Gossip as cultural memory . / Mitchell, Dominic; Bryson, Joanna J; Rauwolf, Paul; Ingram, Gordon.

In: Interaction Studies, Vol. 17, No. 1, 10.2016, p. 1-25.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ad092f9f106f4258bf1cd78dac1319b6,
title = "On the reliability of unreliable information: Gossip as cultural memory",
abstract = "When individuals learn from what others tell them, the information is subject to transmission error that does not arise in learning from direct experience. Yet evidence shows that humans consistently prefer this apparently more unreliable source of information. We examine the effect this preference has in cases where the information concerns a judgment on others’ behaviour and is used to establish cooperation in a society. We present a spatial model confirming that cooperation can be sustained by gossip containing a high degree of uncertainty. Accuracy alone does not predict the value of information in evolutionary terms; relevance, the impact of information on behavioural outcomes, must also be considered. We then show that once relevance is incorporated as a criterion, second-hand information can no longer be discounted on the basis of its poor fidelity alone. Finally we show that the relative importance of accuracy and relevance depends on factors of life history and demography.",
author = "Dominic Mitchell and Bryson, {Joanna J} and Paul Rauwolf and Gordon Ingram",
year = "2016",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1075/is.17.1.01mit",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "1--25",
journal = "Interaction Studies",
issn = "1572-0373",
publisher = "John Benjamins Publishing Company",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - On the reliability of unreliable information

T2 - Interaction Studies

AU - Mitchell, Dominic

AU - Bryson, Joanna J

AU - Rauwolf, Paul

AU - Ingram, Gordon

PY - 2016/10

Y1 - 2016/10

N2 - When individuals learn from what others tell them, the information is subject to transmission error that does not arise in learning from direct experience. Yet evidence shows that humans consistently prefer this apparently more unreliable source of information. We examine the effect this preference has in cases where the information concerns a judgment on others’ behaviour and is used to establish cooperation in a society. We present a spatial model confirming that cooperation can be sustained by gossip containing a high degree of uncertainty. Accuracy alone does not predict the value of information in evolutionary terms; relevance, the impact of information on behavioural outcomes, must also be considered. We then show that once relevance is incorporated as a criterion, second-hand information can no longer be discounted on the basis of its poor fidelity alone. Finally we show that the relative importance of accuracy and relevance depends on factors of life history and demography.

AB - When individuals learn from what others tell them, the information is subject to transmission error that does not arise in learning from direct experience. Yet evidence shows that humans consistently prefer this apparently more unreliable source of information. We examine the effect this preference has in cases where the information concerns a judgment on others’ behaviour and is used to establish cooperation in a society. We present a spatial model confirming that cooperation can be sustained by gossip containing a high degree of uncertainty. Accuracy alone does not predict the value of information in evolutionary terms; relevance, the impact of information on behavioural outcomes, must also be considered. We then show that once relevance is incorporated as a criterion, second-hand information can no longer be discounted on the basis of its poor fidelity alone. Finally we show that the relative importance of accuracy and relevance depends on factors of life history and demography.

U2 - 10.1075/is.17.1.01mit

DO - 10.1075/is.17.1.01mit

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 1

EP - 25

JO - Interaction Studies

JF - Interaction Studies

SN - 1572-0373

IS - 1

ER -