Mitigation versus adaptation: does insulating dwellings increase overheating risk?

Daniel Fosas, David Coley, Sukumar Natarajan, Manuel Herrera, Miguel Fosas de Pando, Alfonso Ramallo-González

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Given climate change predictions of a warmer world, there is growing concern that insulation-led improvements in building fabric aimed at reducing carbon emissions will exacerbate overheating. If true, this would seriously affect building regulations all over the world which have moved towards increased insulation regimes. Despite extensive research, the literature has failed to resolve the controversy of insulation performance, primarily due to varied scope and limited comparability of results.

We approach this problem through carefully constructed pairwise comparisons designed to isolate the effect of insulation on overheating. We encompass the complete range of relevant variables: latitude, climate, insulation, thermal mass, glazing ratio, shading, occupancy, infiltration, ventilation, orientation, and thermal comfort models — creating 576,000 building variants. Data mining techniques are implemented in a novel framework to analyse this large dataset. To provide confidence, the modelling was validated against data collected from well-insulated dwellings.

Our results demonstrate that all parameters have a significant impact on overheating risk. Although insulation is seen to both decrease and increase overheating, depending on the influence of other parameters, parameter ranking shows that insulation only accounts for up to 5% of overall overheating response. Indeed, in cases that are not already overheating through poor design, there is a strong overall tendency for increased insulation to reduce overheating. These results suggest that, in cases with acceptable overheating levels (below 3.7%), the use of improved insulation levels as part of a national climate change mitigation policy is not only sensible, but also helps deliver better indoor thermal environments.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)740-759
Number of pages20
JournalBuilding and Environment
Volume143
Early online date26 Jul 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2018

Fingerprint

insulation
Insulation
mitigation
climate change
subversion
ranking
confidence
climate
Climate change
regime
regulation
performance
Thermal comfort
dwelling
data mining
Thermal insulation
carbon emission
shading
Infiltration
Ventilation

Keywords

  • Building simulation
  • Energy policy
  • Insulation
  • Overheating
  • Thermal comfort

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Engineering
  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Geography, Planning and Development
  • Building and Construction

Cite this

Mitigation versus adaptation: does insulating dwellings increase overheating risk? / Fosas, Daniel; Coley, David; Natarajan, Sukumar; Herrera, Manuel; Fosas de Pando, Miguel; Ramallo-González, Alfonso.

In: Building and Environment, Vol. 143, 01.10.2018, p. 740-759.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fosas, Daniel ; Coley, David ; Natarajan, Sukumar ; Herrera, Manuel ; Fosas de Pando, Miguel ; Ramallo-González, Alfonso. / Mitigation versus adaptation: does insulating dwellings increase overheating risk?. In: Building and Environment. 2018 ; Vol. 143. pp. 740-759.
@article{33dedff3a01d4ee59746c8e28b3d6b49,
title = "Mitigation versus adaptation: does insulating dwellings increase overheating risk?",
abstract = "Given climate change predictions of a warmer world, there is growing concern that insulation-led improvements in building fabric aimed at reducing carbon emissions will exacerbate overheating. If true, this would seriously affect building regulations all over the world which have moved towards increased insulation regimes. Despite extensive research, the literature has failed to resolve the controversy of insulation performance, primarily due to varied scope and limited comparability of results.We approach this problem through carefully constructed pairwise comparisons designed to isolate the effect of insulation on overheating. We encompass the complete range of relevant variables: latitude, climate, insulation, thermal mass, glazing ratio, shading, occupancy, infiltration, ventilation, orientation, and thermal comfort models — creating 576,000 building variants. Data mining techniques are implemented in a novel framework to analyse this large dataset. To provide confidence, the modelling was validated against data collected from well-insulated dwellings.Our results demonstrate that all parameters have a significant impact on overheating risk. Although insulation is seen to both decrease and increase overheating, depending on the influence of other parameters, parameter ranking shows that insulation only accounts for up to 5{\%} of overall overheating response. Indeed, in cases that are not already overheating through poor design, there is a strong overall tendency for increased insulation to reduce overheating. These results suggest that, in cases with acceptable overheating levels (below 3.7{\%}), the use of improved insulation levels as part of a national climate change mitigation policy is not only sensible, but also helps deliver better indoor thermal environments.",
keywords = "Building simulation, Energy policy, Insulation, Overheating, Thermal comfort",
author = "Daniel Fosas and David Coley and Sukumar Natarajan and Manuel Herrera and {Fosas de Pando}, Miguel and Alfonso Ramallo-Gonz{\'a}lez",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.buildenv.2018.07.033",
language = "English",
volume = "143",
pages = "740--759",
journal = "Building and Environment",
issn = "0360-1323",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mitigation versus adaptation: does insulating dwellings increase overheating risk?

AU - Fosas, Daniel

AU - Coley, David

AU - Natarajan, Sukumar

AU - Herrera, Manuel

AU - Fosas de Pando, Miguel

AU - Ramallo-González, Alfonso

PY - 2018/10/1

Y1 - 2018/10/1

N2 - Given climate change predictions of a warmer world, there is growing concern that insulation-led improvements in building fabric aimed at reducing carbon emissions will exacerbate overheating. If true, this would seriously affect building regulations all over the world which have moved towards increased insulation regimes. Despite extensive research, the literature has failed to resolve the controversy of insulation performance, primarily due to varied scope and limited comparability of results.We approach this problem through carefully constructed pairwise comparisons designed to isolate the effect of insulation on overheating. We encompass the complete range of relevant variables: latitude, climate, insulation, thermal mass, glazing ratio, shading, occupancy, infiltration, ventilation, orientation, and thermal comfort models — creating 576,000 building variants. Data mining techniques are implemented in a novel framework to analyse this large dataset. To provide confidence, the modelling was validated against data collected from well-insulated dwellings.Our results demonstrate that all parameters have a significant impact on overheating risk. Although insulation is seen to both decrease and increase overheating, depending on the influence of other parameters, parameter ranking shows that insulation only accounts for up to 5% of overall overheating response. Indeed, in cases that are not already overheating through poor design, there is a strong overall tendency for increased insulation to reduce overheating. These results suggest that, in cases with acceptable overheating levels (below 3.7%), the use of improved insulation levels as part of a national climate change mitigation policy is not only sensible, but also helps deliver better indoor thermal environments.

AB - Given climate change predictions of a warmer world, there is growing concern that insulation-led improvements in building fabric aimed at reducing carbon emissions will exacerbate overheating. If true, this would seriously affect building regulations all over the world which have moved towards increased insulation regimes. Despite extensive research, the literature has failed to resolve the controversy of insulation performance, primarily due to varied scope and limited comparability of results.We approach this problem through carefully constructed pairwise comparisons designed to isolate the effect of insulation on overheating. We encompass the complete range of relevant variables: latitude, climate, insulation, thermal mass, glazing ratio, shading, occupancy, infiltration, ventilation, orientation, and thermal comfort models — creating 576,000 building variants. Data mining techniques are implemented in a novel framework to analyse this large dataset. To provide confidence, the modelling was validated against data collected from well-insulated dwellings.Our results demonstrate that all parameters have a significant impact on overheating risk. Although insulation is seen to both decrease and increase overheating, depending on the influence of other parameters, parameter ranking shows that insulation only accounts for up to 5% of overall overheating response. Indeed, in cases that are not already overheating through poor design, there is a strong overall tendency for increased insulation to reduce overheating. These results suggest that, in cases with acceptable overheating levels (below 3.7%), the use of improved insulation levels as part of a national climate change mitigation policy is not only sensible, but also helps deliver better indoor thermal environments.

KW - Building simulation

KW - Energy policy

KW - Insulation

KW - Overheating

KW - Thermal comfort

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85051552884&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.buildenv.2018.07.033

DO - 10.1016/j.buildenv.2018.07.033

M3 - Article

VL - 143

SP - 740

EP - 759

JO - Building and Environment

JF - Building and Environment

SN - 0360-1323

ER -