Locke and Hume’s theory of color is interrogated through a case study of Esref Armagan, an artist born blind

Simon Hayhoe, Ruby Cohen, Helena Garcia-Carrisoza

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This article investigates Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color, through a study of the fine art practice of Esref Armagan,a Turkish artist who has never seen. The philosophical theory of color is important to the cultural history of blindness, as it has been used to justify early curricula in schools for the blind. This study is based on the following research question: Can people who are born blind understand color in the fine arts? The study is part of a grounded methodology study of art practices and visual impairment, whose findings informed a participatory study of museum access. This article examines part of the study’s first phase,and focuses on the practice of the Turkish artist, Esref Armagan, who was born without sight. Data was collected through a translated correspondence interview with Esref Armagan, and an examination of research articles focusing on Esref’s drawing skills. The study’s data is analyzed using Anderson, Krathwohl &Bloom’s learning hierarchy. It is found that Esref has an extensive knowledge of color and other visual concepts, developed symbolically. What’s more, not only has Esref a knowledge of color, but he can use this knowledge creatively in accordance with Anderson, Krathwohl & Bloom’s highest level of learning(level 6). The article concludes that Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color can be challenged in the context of the creative fine arts, as Esref could develop unique, creative images using color.Therefore, our application of the philosophical theory of color on the education of students with visual impairments, and the pedagogical and andragogical practice based on these theories should be questioned.

Original languageEnglish
Article number3
JournalJournal of Blindness Innovation and Research
Volume9
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Jun 2019

Fingerprint

artist
learning
museum
disability
curriculum
methodology
ability
school

Keywords

  • Hume
  • Locke
  • Blind
  • Theory
  • Art
  • Artist
  • Color
  • philosophy of mind
  • theory of mind

Cite this

Locke and Hume’s theory of color is interrogated through a case study of Esref Armagan, an artist born blind. / Hayhoe, Simon; Cohen, Ruby; Garcia-Carrisoza, Helena.

In: Journal of Blindness Innovation and Research, Vol. 9, No. 1, 3, 30.06.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{5e5483b4a360403e885bcdcc94b842ee,
title = "Locke and Hume’s theory of color is interrogated through a case study of Esref Armagan, an artist born blind",
abstract = "This article investigates Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color, through a study of the fine art practice of Esref Armagan,a Turkish artist who has never seen. The philosophical theory of color is important to the cultural history of blindness, as it has been used to justify early curricula in schools for the blind. This study is based on the following research question: Can people who are born blind understand color in the fine arts? The study is part of a grounded methodology study of art practices and visual impairment, whose findings informed a participatory study of museum access. This article examines part of the study’s first phase,and focuses on the practice of the Turkish artist, Esref Armagan, who was born without sight. Data was collected through a translated correspondence interview with Esref Armagan, and an examination of research articles focusing on Esref’s drawing skills. The study’s data is analyzed using Anderson, Krathwohl &Bloom’s learning hierarchy. It is found that Esref has an extensive knowledge of color and other visual concepts, developed symbolically. What’s more, not only has Esref a knowledge of color, but he can use this knowledge creatively in accordance with Anderson, Krathwohl & Bloom’s highest level of learning(level 6). The article concludes that Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color can be challenged in the context of the creative fine arts, as Esref could develop unique, creative images using color.Therefore, our application of the philosophical theory of color on the education of students with visual impairments, and the pedagogical and andragogical practice based on these theories should be questioned.",
keywords = "Hume, Locke, Blind, Theory, Art, Artist, Color, philosophy of mind, theory of mind",
author = "Simon Hayhoe and Ruby Cohen and Helena Garcia-Carrisoza",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "30",
doi = "10.5241/9-149",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
journal = "Journal of Blindness Innovation and Research",
issn = "2155-2894",
publisher = "National Federation of the Blind",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Locke and Hume’s theory of color is interrogated through a case study of Esref Armagan, an artist born blind

AU - Hayhoe, Simon

AU - Cohen, Ruby

AU - Garcia-Carrisoza, Helena

PY - 2019/6/30

Y1 - 2019/6/30

N2 - This article investigates Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color, through a study of the fine art practice of Esref Armagan,a Turkish artist who has never seen. The philosophical theory of color is important to the cultural history of blindness, as it has been used to justify early curricula in schools for the blind. This study is based on the following research question: Can people who are born blind understand color in the fine arts? The study is part of a grounded methodology study of art practices and visual impairment, whose findings informed a participatory study of museum access. This article examines part of the study’s first phase,and focuses on the practice of the Turkish artist, Esref Armagan, who was born without sight. Data was collected through a translated correspondence interview with Esref Armagan, and an examination of research articles focusing on Esref’s drawing skills. The study’s data is analyzed using Anderson, Krathwohl &Bloom’s learning hierarchy. It is found that Esref has an extensive knowledge of color and other visual concepts, developed symbolically. What’s more, not only has Esref a knowledge of color, but he can use this knowledge creatively in accordance with Anderson, Krathwohl & Bloom’s highest level of learning(level 6). The article concludes that Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color can be challenged in the context of the creative fine arts, as Esref could develop unique, creative images using color.Therefore, our application of the philosophical theory of color on the education of students with visual impairments, and the pedagogical and andragogical practice based on these theories should be questioned.

AB - This article investigates Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color, through a study of the fine art practice of Esref Armagan,a Turkish artist who has never seen. The philosophical theory of color is important to the cultural history of blindness, as it has been used to justify early curricula in schools for the blind. This study is based on the following research question: Can people who are born blind understand color in the fine arts? The study is part of a grounded methodology study of art practices and visual impairment, whose findings informed a participatory study of museum access. This article examines part of the study’s first phase,and focuses on the practice of the Turkish artist, Esref Armagan, who was born without sight. Data was collected through a translated correspondence interview with Esref Armagan, and an examination of research articles focusing on Esref’s drawing skills. The study’s data is analyzed using Anderson, Krathwohl &Bloom’s learning hierarchy. It is found that Esref has an extensive knowledge of color and other visual concepts, developed symbolically. What’s more, not only has Esref a knowledge of color, but he can use this knowledge creatively in accordance with Anderson, Krathwohl & Bloom’s highest level of learning(level 6). The article concludes that Locke and Hume’s philosophical theory of color can be challenged in the context of the creative fine arts, as Esref could develop unique, creative images using color.Therefore, our application of the philosophical theory of color on the education of students with visual impairments, and the pedagogical and andragogical practice based on these theories should be questioned.

KW - Hume

KW - Locke

KW - Blind

KW - Theory

KW - Art

KW - Artist

KW - Color

KW - philosophy of mind

KW - theory of mind

U2 - 10.5241/9-149

DO - 10.5241/9-149

M3 - Article

VL - 9

JO - Journal of Blindness Innovation and Research

JF - Journal of Blindness Innovation and Research

SN - 2155-2894

IS - 1

M1 - 3

ER -