Hospital doctors' anxieties at work: Patient care as intersubjective relationship and/or as system output

Paula Lökman, Yiannis Gabriel, Paula Nicolson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to examine how maternity doctors deal with anxieties generated through their interactions with patients. Design/methodology/approach: The authors juxtapose two critical stories, collected as part of a large mixed method field study of leadership and patient care in three UK hospitals. The study of "organizational stories" is particularly relevant in health care settings that are liable to unleash strong emotions and fantasies, stories have a great advantage of offering an outlet for unconscious emotions and fantasies. The authors collected stories (n=48) from different stakeholders, and after extensive discussions and analysis, it was decided to focus this article on two stories told by two different doctors. These stories sum up not only the storytellers' own personal experiences but also reveal something more profound and general about the nature of doctors' anxieties and the means used to contain them. By restricting the discussion to two narratives, many variations are left outside our remit; the benefit, however, is that the nuances contained in these stories can be looked at in far greater detail. Findings: The principal cause of doctors' anxiety in this study was a constant balancing between an objectifying "I-it" and a communicative "I-Thou" relations with their patients and the organization. If the doctors were unable to deliver what in their personal scale would have been good or even satisfactory patient care, anxiety levels started rising. The coping with and managing of anxiety was mainly done through controlling of relations with patients and colleagues. Originality/value: The paper offers insights into situations that prompt diverse challenging emotions.

LanguageEnglish
Pages29-48
Number of pages20
JournalInternational Journal of Organizational Analysis
Volume19
Issue number1
DOIs
StatusPublished - Mar 2011

Fingerprint

Doctors
Anxiety
Patient care
Emotion
Fantasy
Stakeholders
Field study
Interaction
Mixed methods
Healthcare
Design methodology

Keywords

  • Doctors
  • Patient care
  • Phenomenology
  • Social interaction
  • Storytelling
  • Stress
  • Unconscious phantasies

Cite this

Hospital doctors' anxieties at work : Patient care as intersubjective relationship and/or as system output. / Lökman, Paula; Gabriel, Yiannis; Nicolson, Paula.

In: International Journal of Organizational Analysis, Vol. 19, No. 1, 03.2011, p. 29-48.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ea9f60d3ccca43798b6a6c91f48b90b4,
title = "Hospital doctors' anxieties at work: Patient care as intersubjective relationship and/or as system output",
abstract = "Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to examine how maternity doctors deal with anxieties generated through their interactions with patients. Design/methodology/approach: The authors juxtapose two critical stories, collected as part of a large mixed method field study of leadership and patient care in three UK hospitals. The study of {"}organizational stories{"} is particularly relevant in health care settings that are liable to unleash strong emotions and fantasies, stories have a great advantage of offering an outlet for unconscious emotions and fantasies. The authors collected stories (n=48) from different stakeholders, and after extensive discussions and analysis, it was decided to focus this article on two stories told by two different doctors. These stories sum up not only the storytellers' own personal experiences but also reveal something more profound and general about the nature of doctors' anxieties and the means used to contain them. By restricting the discussion to two narratives, many variations are left outside our remit; the benefit, however, is that the nuances contained in these stories can be looked at in far greater detail. Findings: The principal cause of doctors' anxiety in this study was a constant balancing between an objectifying {"}I-it{"} and a communicative {"}I-Thou{"} relations with their patients and the organization. If the doctors were unable to deliver what in their personal scale would have been good or even satisfactory patient care, anxiety levels started rising. The coping with and managing of anxiety was mainly done through controlling of relations with patients and colleagues. Originality/value: The paper offers insights into situations that prompt diverse challenging emotions.",
keywords = "Doctors, Patient care, Phenomenology, Social interaction, Storytelling, Stress, Unconscious phantasies",
author = "Paula L{\"o}kman and Yiannis Gabriel and Paula Nicolson",
year = "2011",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1108/19348831111121295",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "29--48",
journal = "International Journal of Organizational Analysis",
issn = "1934-8835",
publisher = "Emerald Group Publishing Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Hospital doctors' anxieties at work

T2 - International Journal of Organizational Analysis

AU - Lökman, Paula

AU - Gabriel, Yiannis

AU - Nicolson, Paula

PY - 2011/3

Y1 - 2011/3

N2 - Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to examine how maternity doctors deal with anxieties generated through their interactions with patients. Design/methodology/approach: The authors juxtapose two critical stories, collected as part of a large mixed method field study of leadership and patient care in three UK hospitals. The study of "organizational stories" is particularly relevant in health care settings that are liable to unleash strong emotions and fantasies, stories have a great advantage of offering an outlet for unconscious emotions and fantasies. The authors collected stories (n=48) from different stakeholders, and after extensive discussions and analysis, it was decided to focus this article on two stories told by two different doctors. These stories sum up not only the storytellers' own personal experiences but also reveal something more profound and general about the nature of doctors' anxieties and the means used to contain them. By restricting the discussion to two narratives, many variations are left outside our remit; the benefit, however, is that the nuances contained in these stories can be looked at in far greater detail. Findings: The principal cause of doctors' anxiety in this study was a constant balancing between an objectifying "I-it" and a communicative "I-Thou" relations with their patients and the organization. If the doctors were unable to deliver what in their personal scale would have been good or even satisfactory patient care, anxiety levels started rising. The coping with and managing of anxiety was mainly done through controlling of relations with patients and colleagues. Originality/value: The paper offers insights into situations that prompt diverse challenging emotions.

AB - Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to examine how maternity doctors deal with anxieties generated through their interactions with patients. Design/methodology/approach: The authors juxtapose two critical stories, collected as part of a large mixed method field study of leadership and patient care in three UK hospitals. The study of "organizational stories" is particularly relevant in health care settings that are liable to unleash strong emotions and fantasies, stories have a great advantage of offering an outlet for unconscious emotions and fantasies. The authors collected stories (n=48) from different stakeholders, and after extensive discussions and analysis, it was decided to focus this article on two stories told by two different doctors. These stories sum up not only the storytellers' own personal experiences but also reveal something more profound and general about the nature of doctors' anxieties and the means used to contain them. By restricting the discussion to two narratives, many variations are left outside our remit; the benefit, however, is that the nuances contained in these stories can be looked at in far greater detail. Findings: The principal cause of doctors' anxiety in this study was a constant balancing between an objectifying "I-it" and a communicative "I-Thou" relations with their patients and the organization. If the doctors were unable to deliver what in their personal scale would have been good or even satisfactory patient care, anxiety levels started rising. The coping with and managing of anxiety was mainly done through controlling of relations with patients and colleagues. Originality/value: The paper offers insights into situations that prompt diverse challenging emotions.

KW - Doctors

KW - Patient care

KW - Phenomenology

KW - Social interaction

KW - Storytelling

KW - Stress

KW - Unconscious phantasies

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79952326433&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/19348831111121295

U2 - 10.1108/19348831111121295

DO - 10.1108/19348831111121295

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 29

EP - 48

JO - International Journal of Organizational Analysis

JF - International Journal of Organizational Analysis

SN - 1934-8835

IS - 1

ER -