Habit Modification of the Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Lovastatin Through a Predictive Solvent Selection Approach

Thomas D. Turner, Lauren E. Hatcher, Chick C. Wilson, Kevin J. Roberts

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

An analysis of the important intermolecular interactions of the active pharmaceutical ingredient lovastatin which contribute to the surface chemistry and attachment energy morphology is presented. The analysis is supported by a recent redetermination of the single-crystal structure (orthorhombic space group P2 1 2 1 2 1 ) and targets the understanding and potential control of the morphology of lovastatin, which tends to crystallize in a needle-like morphology, where the aspect ratio varies depending on the nature of the solvent. The lattice energy was calculated to be −38.79 kcal mol −1 with a small contribution of −2.73 kcal mol −1 from electrostatic interactions. The lattice structure is significantly stabilized by the hexahydronaphthalene ring of the molecule, which contributes 43.39% of the lattice energy. Synthon analysis shows that the dominant intermolecular interaction within the lattice structure of lovastatin is found to be along the a crystallographic axis, associated with a dispersive stacking interaction due to the close packing of 2 hexahydronaphthalene rings resulting in a total interaction energy of −6.46 kcal mol −1 . The attachment energy morphology correlates well with the observed crystal morphology which exhibits a needle-like habit dominated by {0 1 1}, {0 2 0}, {0 0 2}, and {1 0 1} crystal forms. The needle capping faces are found to contain the short stacks of hexahydronaphthalene rings where the strong intermolecular synthon is found to contribute positively to the attachment energy and hence growth at this surface. This dominant intermolecular synthon is concluded to be the major cause of enhanced growth along the crystallographic a axis leading to the formation of a needle-like morphology. A habit modification strategy is discussed which uses recrystallization from apolar solvents to reduce the effective growth rate at the needle-capping surfaces. This is supported through experimental data which shows that crystals obtained from crystallization in hexane and methyl-cyclohexane have significantly reduced aspect ratios in comparison to those grown from the more polar methanol and ethyl acetate solutions. Crystals obtained from nitromethane solutions were also found to have a very large reduction in aspect ratio to a prismatic morphology reflecting this solvent's propensity to interact with hydrophobic surfaces, critically with no polymorph change.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1779-1787
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Pharmaceutical Sciences
Volume108
Issue number5
Early online date24 Dec 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 May 2019

Keywords

  • lattice energy
  • lovastatin
  • molecular modeling
  • morphology prediction
  • surface chemistry
  • synthonic engineering

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pharmaceutical Science

Cite this

Habit Modification of the Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Lovastatin Through a Predictive Solvent Selection Approach. / Turner, Thomas D.; Hatcher, Lauren E.; Wilson, Chick C.; Roberts, Kevin J.

In: Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Vol. 108, No. 5, 31.05.2019, p. 1779-1787.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{8056c3ba2d3d4db7b19a214d13b9a1cf,
title = "Habit Modification of the Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Lovastatin Through a Predictive Solvent Selection Approach",
abstract = "An analysis of the important intermolecular interactions of the active pharmaceutical ingredient lovastatin which contribute to the surface chemistry and attachment energy morphology is presented. The analysis is supported by a recent redetermination of the single-crystal structure (orthorhombic space group P2 1 2 1 2 1 ) and targets the understanding and potential control of the morphology of lovastatin, which tends to crystallize in a needle-like morphology, where the aspect ratio varies depending on the nature of the solvent. The lattice energy was calculated to be −38.79 kcal mol −1 with a small contribution of −2.73 kcal mol −1 from electrostatic interactions. The lattice structure is significantly stabilized by the hexahydronaphthalene ring of the molecule, which contributes 43.39{\%} of the lattice energy. Synthon analysis shows that the dominant intermolecular interaction within the lattice structure of lovastatin is found to be along the a crystallographic axis, associated with a dispersive stacking interaction due to the close packing of 2 hexahydronaphthalene rings resulting in a total interaction energy of −6.46 kcal mol −1 . The attachment energy morphology correlates well with the observed crystal morphology which exhibits a needle-like habit dominated by {0 1 1}, {0 2 0}, {0 0 2}, and {1 0 1} crystal forms. The needle capping faces are found to contain the short stacks of hexahydronaphthalene rings where the strong intermolecular synthon is found to contribute positively to the attachment energy and hence growth at this surface. This dominant intermolecular synthon is concluded to be the major cause of enhanced growth along the crystallographic a axis leading to the formation of a needle-like morphology. A habit modification strategy is discussed which uses recrystallization from apolar solvents to reduce the effective growth rate at the needle-capping surfaces. This is supported through experimental data which shows that crystals obtained from crystallization in hexane and methyl-cyclohexane have significantly reduced aspect ratios in comparison to those grown from the more polar methanol and ethyl acetate solutions. Crystals obtained from nitromethane solutions were also found to have a very large reduction in aspect ratio to a prismatic morphology reflecting this solvent's propensity to interact with hydrophobic surfaces, critically with no polymorph change.",
keywords = "lattice energy, lovastatin, molecular modeling, morphology prediction, surface chemistry, synthonic engineering",
author = "Turner, {Thomas D.} and Hatcher, {Lauren E.} and Wilson, {Chick C.} and Roberts, {Kevin J.}",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1016/j.xphs.2018.12.012",
language = "English",
volume = "108",
pages = "1779--1787",
journal = "Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences",
issn = "0022-3549",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Habit Modification of the Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Lovastatin Through a Predictive Solvent Selection Approach

AU - Turner, Thomas D.

AU - Hatcher, Lauren E.

AU - Wilson, Chick C.

AU - Roberts, Kevin J.

PY - 2019/5/31

Y1 - 2019/5/31

N2 - An analysis of the important intermolecular interactions of the active pharmaceutical ingredient lovastatin which contribute to the surface chemistry and attachment energy morphology is presented. The analysis is supported by a recent redetermination of the single-crystal structure (orthorhombic space group P2 1 2 1 2 1 ) and targets the understanding and potential control of the morphology of lovastatin, which tends to crystallize in a needle-like morphology, where the aspect ratio varies depending on the nature of the solvent. The lattice energy was calculated to be −38.79 kcal mol −1 with a small contribution of −2.73 kcal mol −1 from electrostatic interactions. The lattice structure is significantly stabilized by the hexahydronaphthalene ring of the molecule, which contributes 43.39% of the lattice energy. Synthon analysis shows that the dominant intermolecular interaction within the lattice structure of lovastatin is found to be along the a crystallographic axis, associated with a dispersive stacking interaction due to the close packing of 2 hexahydronaphthalene rings resulting in a total interaction energy of −6.46 kcal mol −1 . The attachment energy morphology correlates well with the observed crystal morphology which exhibits a needle-like habit dominated by {0 1 1}, {0 2 0}, {0 0 2}, and {1 0 1} crystal forms. The needle capping faces are found to contain the short stacks of hexahydronaphthalene rings where the strong intermolecular synthon is found to contribute positively to the attachment energy and hence growth at this surface. This dominant intermolecular synthon is concluded to be the major cause of enhanced growth along the crystallographic a axis leading to the formation of a needle-like morphology. A habit modification strategy is discussed which uses recrystallization from apolar solvents to reduce the effective growth rate at the needle-capping surfaces. This is supported through experimental data which shows that crystals obtained from crystallization in hexane and methyl-cyclohexane have significantly reduced aspect ratios in comparison to those grown from the more polar methanol and ethyl acetate solutions. Crystals obtained from nitromethane solutions were also found to have a very large reduction in aspect ratio to a prismatic morphology reflecting this solvent's propensity to interact with hydrophobic surfaces, critically with no polymorph change.

AB - An analysis of the important intermolecular interactions of the active pharmaceutical ingredient lovastatin which contribute to the surface chemistry and attachment energy morphology is presented. The analysis is supported by a recent redetermination of the single-crystal structure (orthorhombic space group P2 1 2 1 2 1 ) and targets the understanding and potential control of the morphology of lovastatin, which tends to crystallize in a needle-like morphology, where the aspect ratio varies depending on the nature of the solvent. The lattice energy was calculated to be −38.79 kcal mol −1 with a small contribution of −2.73 kcal mol −1 from electrostatic interactions. The lattice structure is significantly stabilized by the hexahydronaphthalene ring of the molecule, which contributes 43.39% of the lattice energy. Synthon analysis shows that the dominant intermolecular interaction within the lattice structure of lovastatin is found to be along the a crystallographic axis, associated with a dispersive stacking interaction due to the close packing of 2 hexahydronaphthalene rings resulting in a total interaction energy of −6.46 kcal mol −1 . The attachment energy morphology correlates well with the observed crystal morphology which exhibits a needle-like habit dominated by {0 1 1}, {0 2 0}, {0 0 2}, and {1 0 1} crystal forms. The needle capping faces are found to contain the short stacks of hexahydronaphthalene rings where the strong intermolecular synthon is found to contribute positively to the attachment energy and hence growth at this surface. This dominant intermolecular synthon is concluded to be the major cause of enhanced growth along the crystallographic a axis leading to the formation of a needle-like morphology. A habit modification strategy is discussed which uses recrystallization from apolar solvents to reduce the effective growth rate at the needle-capping surfaces. This is supported through experimental data which shows that crystals obtained from crystallization in hexane and methyl-cyclohexane have significantly reduced aspect ratios in comparison to those grown from the more polar methanol and ethyl acetate solutions. Crystals obtained from nitromethane solutions were also found to have a very large reduction in aspect ratio to a prismatic morphology reflecting this solvent's propensity to interact with hydrophobic surfaces, critically with no polymorph change.

KW - lattice energy

KW - lovastatin

KW - molecular modeling

KW - morphology prediction

KW - surface chemistry

KW - synthonic engineering

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85061384306&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.xphs.2018.12.012

DO - 10.1016/j.xphs.2018.12.012

M3 - Article

VL - 108

SP - 1779

EP - 1787

JO - Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences

JF - Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences

SN - 0022-3549

IS - 5

ER -