GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves

P. A. Curran, A. J. van der Horst, R. A.M.J. Wijers, R. L.C. Starling, A. J. Castro-Tirado, J. P.U. Fynbo, J. Gorosabel, A. S. Järvinen, D. Malesani, E. Rol, N. R. Tanvir, K. Wiersema, M. R. Burleigh, S. L. Casewell, P. D. Dobbie, S. Guziy, P. Jakobsson, M. Jelínek, P. Laursen, A. J. Levan & 3 others C. G. Mundell, J. Näränen, S. Piranomonte

Research output: Contribution to journalLetter

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Gamma-ray burst afterglow observations in the Swift era have a perceived lack of achromatic jet breaks compared with the BeppoSAX era. We present our multi-wavelength analysis of GRB 060206 as an illustrative example of how inferences of jet breaks from optical and X-ray data might differ. The results of temporal and spectral analyses are compared, and attempts are made to fit the data within the context of the standard blast wave model. We find that while the break appears more pronounced in the optical and evidence for it from the X-ray alone is weak, the data are actually consistent with an achromatic break at about 16 h. This break and the light curves fit standard blast wave models, either as a jet break or as an injection break. As the pre-Swift sample of afterglows are dominated by optical observations, and in the Swift era most well-sampled light curves are in the X-ray, caution is needed when making a direct comparison between the two samples, and when making definite statements on the absence of achromatic breaks.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)L65-L69
JournalMonthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters
Volume381
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2007

Fingerprint

afterglows
light curve
blasts
x rays
inference
gamma ray bursts
injection
wavelength
wavelengths

Keywords

  • Gamma-rays: bursts
  • Radiation mechanisms: non-thermal
  • X-rays: individual: GRB 060206

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Curran, P. A., van der Horst, A. J., Wijers, R. A. M. J., Starling, R. L. C., Castro-Tirado, A. J., Fynbo, J. P. U., ... Piranomonte, S. (2007). GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters, 381(1), L65-L69. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-3933.2007.00368.x

GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves. / Curran, P. A.; van der Horst, A. J.; Wijers, R. A.M.J.; Starling, R. L.C.; Castro-Tirado, A. J.; Fynbo, J. P.U.; Gorosabel, J.; Järvinen, A. S.; Malesani, D.; Rol, E.; Tanvir, N. R.; Wiersema, K.; Burleigh, M. R.; Casewell, S. L.; Dobbie, P. D.; Guziy, S.; Jakobsson, P.; Jelínek, M.; Laursen, P.; Levan, A. J.; Mundell, C. G.; Näränen, J.; Piranomonte, S.

In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters, Vol. 381, No. 1, 01.10.2007, p. L65-L69.

Research output: Contribution to journalLetter

Curran, PA, van der Horst, AJ, Wijers, RAMJ, Starling, RLC, Castro-Tirado, AJ, Fynbo, JPU, Gorosabel, J, Järvinen, AS, Malesani, D, Rol, E, Tanvir, NR, Wiersema, K, Burleigh, MR, Casewell, SL, Dobbie, PD, Guziy, S, Jakobsson, P, Jelínek, M, Laursen, P, Levan, AJ, Mundell, CG, Näränen, J & Piranomonte, S 2007, 'GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves', Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters, vol. 381, no. 1, pp. L65-L69. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-3933.2007.00368.x
Curran PA, van der Horst AJ, Wijers RAMJ, Starling RLC, Castro-Tirado AJ, Fynbo JPU et al. GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters. 2007 Oct 1;381(1):L65-L69. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-3933.2007.00368.x
Curran, P. A. ; van der Horst, A. J. ; Wijers, R. A.M.J. ; Starling, R. L.C. ; Castro-Tirado, A. J. ; Fynbo, J. P.U. ; Gorosabel, J. ; Järvinen, A. S. ; Malesani, D. ; Rol, E. ; Tanvir, N. R. ; Wiersema, K. ; Burleigh, M. R. ; Casewell, S. L. ; Dobbie, P. D. ; Guziy, S. ; Jakobsson, P. ; Jelínek, M. ; Laursen, P. ; Levan, A. J. ; Mundell, C. G. ; Näränen, J. ; Piranomonte, S. / GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves. In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters. 2007 ; Vol. 381, No. 1. pp. L65-L69.
@article{b414728994c240e6b8d3d0ed5f325221,
title = "GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves",
abstract = "Gamma-ray burst afterglow observations in the Swift era have a perceived lack of achromatic jet breaks compared with the BeppoSAX era. We present our multi-wavelength analysis of GRB 060206 as an illustrative example of how inferences of jet breaks from optical and X-ray data might differ. The results of temporal and spectral analyses are compared, and attempts are made to fit the data within the context of the standard blast wave model. We find that while the break appears more pronounced in the optical and evidence for it from the X-ray alone is weak, the data are actually consistent with an achromatic break at about 16 h. This break and the light curves fit standard blast wave models, either as a jet break or as an injection break. As the pre-Swift sample of afterglows are dominated by optical observations, and in the Swift era most well-sampled light curves are in the X-ray, caution is needed when making a direct comparison between the two samples, and when making definite statements on the absence of achromatic breaks.",
keywords = "Gamma-rays: bursts, Radiation mechanisms: non-thermal, X-rays: individual: GRB 060206",
author = "Curran, {P. A.} and {van der Horst}, {A. J.} and Wijers, {R. A.M.J.} and Starling, {R. L.C.} and Castro-Tirado, {A. J.} and Fynbo, {J. P.U.} and J. Gorosabel and J{\"a}rvinen, {A. S.} and D. Malesani and E. Rol and Tanvir, {N. R.} and K. Wiersema and Burleigh, {M. R.} and Casewell, {S. L.} and Dobbie, {P. D.} and S. Guziy and P. Jakobsson and M. Jel{\'i}nek and P. Laursen and Levan, {A. J.} and Mundell, {C. G.} and J. N{\"a}r{\"a}nen and S. Piranomonte",
year = "2007",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/j.1745-3933.2007.00368.x",
language = "English",
volume = "381",
pages = "L65--L69",
journal = "Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters",
issn = "1745-3933",
publisher = "Oxford Univerity Press",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - GRB 060206 and the quandary of achromatic breaks in afterglow light curves

AU - Curran, P. A.

AU - van der Horst, A. J.

AU - Wijers, R. A.M.J.

AU - Starling, R. L.C.

AU - Castro-Tirado, A. J.

AU - Fynbo, J. P.U.

AU - Gorosabel, J.

AU - Järvinen, A. S.

AU - Malesani, D.

AU - Rol, E.

AU - Tanvir, N. R.

AU - Wiersema, K.

AU - Burleigh, M. R.

AU - Casewell, S. L.

AU - Dobbie, P. D.

AU - Guziy, S.

AU - Jakobsson, P.

AU - Jelínek, M.

AU - Laursen, P.

AU - Levan, A. J.

AU - Mundell, C. G.

AU - Näränen, J.

AU - Piranomonte, S.

PY - 2007/10/1

Y1 - 2007/10/1

N2 - Gamma-ray burst afterglow observations in the Swift era have a perceived lack of achromatic jet breaks compared with the BeppoSAX era. We present our multi-wavelength analysis of GRB 060206 as an illustrative example of how inferences of jet breaks from optical and X-ray data might differ. The results of temporal and spectral analyses are compared, and attempts are made to fit the data within the context of the standard blast wave model. We find that while the break appears more pronounced in the optical and evidence for it from the X-ray alone is weak, the data are actually consistent with an achromatic break at about 16 h. This break and the light curves fit standard blast wave models, either as a jet break or as an injection break. As the pre-Swift sample of afterglows are dominated by optical observations, and in the Swift era most well-sampled light curves are in the X-ray, caution is needed when making a direct comparison between the two samples, and when making definite statements on the absence of achromatic breaks.

AB - Gamma-ray burst afterglow observations in the Swift era have a perceived lack of achromatic jet breaks compared with the BeppoSAX era. We present our multi-wavelength analysis of GRB 060206 as an illustrative example of how inferences of jet breaks from optical and X-ray data might differ. The results of temporal and spectral analyses are compared, and attempts are made to fit the data within the context of the standard blast wave model. We find that while the break appears more pronounced in the optical and evidence for it from the X-ray alone is weak, the data are actually consistent with an achromatic break at about 16 h. This break and the light curves fit standard blast wave models, either as a jet break or as an injection break. As the pre-Swift sample of afterglows are dominated by optical observations, and in the Swift era most well-sampled light curves are in the X-ray, caution is needed when making a direct comparison between the two samples, and when making definite statements on the absence of achromatic breaks.

KW - Gamma-rays: bursts

KW - Radiation mechanisms: non-thermal

KW - X-rays: individual: GRB 060206

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=40249096820&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1745-3933.2007.00368.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1745-3933.2007.00368.x

M3 - Letter

VL - 381

SP - L65-L69

JO - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters

JF - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society: Letters

SN - 1745-3933

IS - 1

ER -