Disipated energy and efficiency as objective functions for the design of the NeoVAD rotary blood pump

Minimising haemolytic blood damage is an important objective when designing rotary blood pumps, however, calculating haemolysis can be computationally expensive and inaccurate. Efficiency and dissipated energy are much more easily calculable hydraulic parameters in the design and analysis of rotary blood pumps and although there is work to suggest that efficiency is not a good indicator of haemocompatibility, i.e. more efficient pumps do not necessarily cause less damage, there is recent speculation that dissipated energy can act as an easily calculable haemolysis analogue.

This study shows that for design purposes, optimising for maximum efficiency and minimum dissipated energy are functionally the same as they are inherently and closely linked. Moreover a demonstration of rotary blood pump design has been completed using the NeoVAD paediatric left ventricular assist device optimising for both objective functions. The resulting designs appear similar in rotor blade shape and are similar in hydraulic performance.

This reinforces the direct link between efficiency and dissipated energy when analysing rotary blood pumps at a given design operating point. This raises questions either of the claim that efficiency cannot be used as an easily calculable analogue for haemolysis or the validity of dissipated energy to act in this same manner.