Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation

Javier Rivas, Carmelo Rodriguez Alvarez

Research output: Working paper

23 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

We analyse committees of voters who take a decision between two options as a two- stage process. In a discussion stage, voters share non-verifiable information about a private signal concerning what is the best option. In a voting stage, votes are cast and one of the options is implemented. We introduce the possibility of leadership whereby a certain voter, the leader, is more influential than the rest at the discussion stage even though she is not better informed. We study information transmission and characterize the effects of the leader on the deliberation process. We find, amongst others, that both the quality of the decision taken by the committee and how truthful voters are at the discussion stage depends non-monotonically on how influential the leader is. In particular, although a leader whose influence is weak does not disrupt the decision process of the committee in any way, a very influential leader is less disruptive than a moderately influential leader.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherUniversidad Complutense de Madrid
VolumeDocumentos de Trabajo del Instituto Complutense de Análisis Económico (ICAE); nº 04, 2014,
Publication statusIn preparation - 2014

Fingerprint

Deliberation
Information aggregation
Voters
Vote
Voting
Information transmission
Decision process

Keywords

  • Committees
  • Voting
  • Leadership
  • Information Aggregation

Cite this

Rivas, J., & Rodriguez Alvarez, C. (2014). Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation. Universidad Complutense de Madrid.

Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation. / Rivas, Javier; Rodriguez Alvarez, Carmelo.

Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 2014.

Research output: Working paper

Rivas, J & Rodriguez Alvarez, C 2014 'Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation' Universidad Complutense de Madrid.
Rivas J, Rodriguez Alvarez C. Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation. Universidad Complutense de Madrid. 2014.
Rivas, Javier ; Rodriguez Alvarez, Carmelo. / Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation. Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 2014.
@techreport{7248a2425f4d41d1a538758547f1cf5d,
title = "Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation",
abstract = "We analyse committees of voters who take a decision between two options as a two- stage process. In a discussion stage, voters share non-verifiable information about a private signal concerning what is the best option. In a voting stage, votes are cast and one of the options is implemented. We introduce the possibility of leadership whereby a certain voter, the leader, is more influential than the rest at the discussion stage even though she is not better informed. We study information transmission and characterize the effects of the leader on the deliberation process. We find, amongst others, that both the quality of the decision taken by the committee and how truthful voters are at the discussion stage depends non-monotonically on how influential the leader is. In particular, although a leader whose influence is weak does not disrupt the decision process of the committee in any way, a very influential leader is less disruptive than a moderately influential leader.",
keywords = "Committees, Voting, Leadership, Information Aggregation",
author = "Javier Rivas and {Rodriguez Alvarez}, Carmelo",
year = "2014",
language = "English",
volume = "Documentos de Trabajo del Instituto Complutense de An{\'a}lisis Econ{\'o}mico (ICAE); nº 04, 2014,",
publisher = "Universidad Complutense de Madrid",
address = "Spain",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Universidad Complutense de Madrid",

}

TY - UNPB

T1 - Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation

AU - Rivas, Javier

AU - Rodriguez Alvarez, Carmelo

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - We analyse committees of voters who take a decision between two options as a two- stage process. In a discussion stage, voters share non-verifiable information about a private signal concerning what is the best option. In a voting stage, votes are cast and one of the options is implemented. We introduce the possibility of leadership whereby a certain voter, the leader, is more influential than the rest at the discussion stage even though she is not better informed. We study information transmission and characterize the effects of the leader on the deliberation process. We find, amongst others, that both the quality of the decision taken by the committee and how truthful voters are at the discussion stage depends non-monotonically on how influential the leader is. In particular, although a leader whose influence is weak does not disrupt the decision process of the committee in any way, a very influential leader is less disruptive than a moderately influential leader.

AB - We analyse committees of voters who take a decision between two options as a two- stage process. In a discussion stage, voters share non-verifiable information about a private signal concerning what is the best option. In a voting stage, votes are cast and one of the options is implemented. We introduce the possibility of leadership whereby a certain voter, the leader, is more influential than the rest at the discussion stage even though she is not better informed. We study information transmission and characterize the effects of the leader on the deliberation process. We find, amongst others, that both the quality of the decision taken by the committee and how truthful voters are at the discussion stage depends non-monotonically on how influential the leader is. In particular, although a leader whose influence is weak does not disrupt the decision process of the committee in any way, a very influential leader is less disruptive than a moderately influential leader.

KW - Committees

KW - Voting

KW - Leadership

KW - Information Aggregation

M3 - Working paper

VL - Documentos de Trabajo del Instituto Complutense de Análisis Económico (ICAE); nº 04, 2014,

BT - Deliberation, Leadership and Information Aggregation

PB - Universidad Complutense de Madrid

ER -