Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles

Julian Stirling, Ioannis Lekkas, Adam Sweetman, Predrag Djuranovic, Quanmin Guo, Brian Pauw, Josef Granwehr, Raphaël Lévy, Philip Moriarty

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

There is now a significant body of literature which reports that stripes form in the ligand shell of suitably functionalised Au nanoparticles. This stripe morphology has been proposed to strongly affect the physicochemical and biochemical properties of the particles. We critique the published evidence for striped nanoparticles in detail, with a particular focus on the interpretation of scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) data (as this is the only technique which ostensibly provides direct evidence for the presence of stripes). Through a combination of an exhaustive re-analysis of the original data, in addition to new experimental measurements of a simple control sample comprising entirely unfunctionalised particles, we show that all of the STM evidence for striped nanoparticles published to date can instead be explained by a combination of well-known instrumental artefacts, or by issues with data acquisition/analysis protocols. We also critically re-examine the evidence for the presence of ligand stripes which has been claimed to have been found from transmission electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, small angle neutron scattering experiments, and computer simulations. Although these data can indeed be interpreted in terms of stripe formation, we show that the reported results can alternatively be explained as arising from a combination of instrumental artefacts and inadequate data analysis techniques.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)e108482
JournalPLoS ONE
Volume9
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 17 Nov 2014

Cite this

Stirling, J., Lekkas, I., Sweetman, A., Djuranovic, P., Guo, Q., Pauw, B., ... Moriarty, P. (2014). Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles. PLoS ONE, 9(11), e108482. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0108482

Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles. / Stirling, Julian; Lekkas, Ioannis; Sweetman, Adam; Djuranovic, Predrag; Guo, Quanmin; Pauw, Brian; Granwehr, Josef; Lévy, Raphaël; Moriarty, Philip.

In: PLoS ONE, Vol. 9, No. 11, 17.11.2014, p. e108482.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Stirling, J, Lekkas, I, Sweetman, A, Djuranovic, P, Guo, Q, Pauw, B, Granwehr, J, Lévy, R & Moriarty, P 2014, 'Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles', PLoS ONE, vol. 9, no. 11, pp. e108482. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0108482
Stirling J, Lekkas I, Sweetman A, Djuranovic P, Guo Q, Pauw B et al. Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles. PLoS ONE. 2014 Nov 17;9(11):e108482. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0108482
Stirling, Julian ; Lekkas, Ioannis ; Sweetman, Adam ; Djuranovic, Predrag ; Guo, Quanmin ; Pauw, Brian ; Granwehr, Josef ; Lévy, Raphaël ; Moriarty, Philip. / Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles. In: PLoS ONE. 2014 ; Vol. 9, No. 11. pp. e108482.
@article{74c85e52aa1349dd8b29e0575c30cf59,
title = "Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles",
abstract = "There is now a significant body of literature which reports that stripes form in the ligand shell of suitably functionalised Au nanoparticles. This stripe morphology has been proposed to strongly affect the physicochemical and biochemical properties of the particles. We critique the published evidence for striped nanoparticles in detail, with a particular focus on the interpretation of scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) data (as this is the only technique which ostensibly provides direct evidence for the presence of stripes). Through a combination of an exhaustive re-analysis of the original data, in addition to new experimental measurements of a simple control sample comprising entirely unfunctionalised particles, we show that all of the STM evidence for striped nanoparticles published to date can instead be explained by a combination of well-known instrumental artefacts, or by issues with data acquisition/analysis protocols. We also critically re-examine the evidence for the presence of ligand stripes which has been claimed to have been found from transmission electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, small angle neutron scattering experiments, and computer simulations. Although these data can indeed be interpreted in terms of stripe formation, we show that the reported results can alternatively be explained as arising from a combination of instrumental artefacts and inadequate data analysis techniques.",
author = "Julian Stirling and Ioannis Lekkas and Adam Sweetman and Predrag Djuranovic and Quanmin Guo and Brian Pauw and Josef Granwehr and Rapha{\"e}l L{\'e}vy and Philip Moriarty",
year = "2014",
month = "11",
day = "17",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0108482",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "e108482",
journal = "PLoS ONE",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science (PLOS)",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Critical assessment of the evidence for striped nanoparticles

AU - Stirling, Julian

AU - Lekkas, Ioannis

AU - Sweetman, Adam

AU - Djuranovic, Predrag

AU - Guo, Quanmin

AU - Pauw, Brian

AU - Granwehr, Josef

AU - Lévy, Raphaël

AU - Moriarty, Philip

PY - 2014/11/17

Y1 - 2014/11/17

N2 - There is now a significant body of literature which reports that stripes form in the ligand shell of suitably functionalised Au nanoparticles. This stripe morphology has been proposed to strongly affect the physicochemical and biochemical properties of the particles. We critique the published evidence for striped nanoparticles in detail, with a particular focus on the interpretation of scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) data (as this is the only technique which ostensibly provides direct evidence for the presence of stripes). Through a combination of an exhaustive re-analysis of the original data, in addition to new experimental measurements of a simple control sample comprising entirely unfunctionalised particles, we show that all of the STM evidence for striped nanoparticles published to date can instead be explained by a combination of well-known instrumental artefacts, or by issues with data acquisition/analysis protocols. We also critically re-examine the evidence for the presence of ligand stripes which has been claimed to have been found from transmission electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, small angle neutron scattering experiments, and computer simulations. Although these data can indeed be interpreted in terms of stripe formation, we show that the reported results can alternatively be explained as arising from a combination of instrumental artefacts and inadequate data analysis techniques.

AB - There is now a significant body of literature which reports that stripes form in the ligand shell of suitably functionalised Au nanoparticles. This stripe morphology has been proposed to strongly affect the physicochemical and biochemical properties of the particles. We critique the published evidence for striped nanoparticles in detail, with a particular focus on the interpretation of scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) data (as this is the only technique which ostensibly provides direct evidence for the presence of stripes). Through a combination of an exhaustive re-analysis of the original data, in addition to new experimental measurements of a simple control sample comprising entirely unfunctionalised particles, we show that all of the STM evidence for striped nanoparticles published to date can instead be explained by a combination of well-known instrumental artefacts, or by issues with data acquisition/analysis protocols. We also critically re-examine the evidence for the presence of ligand stripes which has been claimed to have been found from transmission electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, small angle neutron scattering experiments, and computer simulations. Although these data can indeed be interpreted in terms of stripe formation, we show that the reported results can alternatively be explained as arising from a combination of instrumental artefacts and inadequate data analysis techniques.

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0108482

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0108482

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - e108482

JO - PLoS ONE

JF - PLoS ONE

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 11

ER -