Converging and diverging governance mechanisms: The dynamic interplay of (dys)function

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper explores governance mechanisms and the dynamic interplay of functional and dysfunctional behaviour, what we term ‘(dys)function’, in long-term inter-organizational relationships. Using two longitudinal cases of warship commissioning we argue although varying degrees of formalization is important when managing long-term relationships, organizations should learn not only to contract or build up trusting relations but consider both together as semi-coupled in terms of the impact such interplay has on performance. We discuss governance mechanisms as moving beyond notions of complementarity and substitution towards a more nuanced view where governance of inter-organizational relationships can be convergent or divergent. Our findings show that what is functional behaviour for one side of the dyad can be dysfunctional for the other party, also that relationships can exhibit functions and dysfunctions across forms of governance simultaneously. Our conclusions suggest that mismatches in governance mechanisms can be positive as well as negative, and it is the overall relationship atmosphere that determines the direction of the (dys)function. In building a context dependent understanding of governance we both summarise the (dys)functions associated with formal and informal governance mechanisms, and explore their impact on relationship exchange performance over time.
LanguageEnglish
Article number10077
JournalAcademy of Management Proceedings
Volume2017
Issue number1
Early online date30 Nov 2017
DOIs
StatusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Governance mechanisms
Governance
Interorganizational relationships
Formalization
Complementarity
Dyads
Long-term relationships
Exchange relationships
Substitution
Mismatch
Atmosphere

Cite this

Converging and diverging governance mechanisms: The dynamic interplay of (dys)function. / Howard, Mickey Bruce; Roehrich, Jens; Lewis, Michael; Squire, Brian.

In: Academy of Management Proceedings, Vol. 2017, No. 1, 10077, 2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e96b4dd033fe4364990afb9905d4054b,
title = "Converging and diverging governance mechanisms: The dynamic interplay of (dys)function",
abstract = "This paper explores governance mechanisms and the dynamic interplay of functional and dysfunctional behaviour, what we term ‘(dys)function’, in long-term inter-organizational relationships. Using two longitudinal cases of warship commissioning we argue although varying degrees of formalization is important when managing long-term relationships, organizations should learn not only to contract or build up trusting relations but consider both together as semi-coupled in terms of the impact such interplay has on performance. We discuss governance mechanisms as moving beyond notions of complementarity and substitution towards a more nuanced view where governance of inter-organizational relationships can be convergent or divergent. Our findings show that what is functional behaviour for one side of the dyad can be dysfunctional for the other party, also that relationships can exhibit functions and dysfunctions across forms of governance simultaneously. Our conclusions suggest that mismatches in governance mechanisms can be positive as well as negative, and it is the overall relationship atmosphere that determines the direction of the (dys)function. In building a context dependent understanding of governance we both summarise the (dys)functions associated with formal and informal governance mechanisms, and explore their impact on relationship exchange performance over time.",
author = "Howard, {Mickey Bruce} and Jens Roehrich and Michael Lewis and Brian Squire",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.5465/ambpp.2017.10077abstract",
language = "English",
volume = "2017",
journal = "Academy of Management Proceedings",
issn = "0065-0668",
publisher = "Academy of Management",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Converging and diverging governance mechanisms: The dynamic interplay of (dys)function

AU - Howard,Mickey Bruce

AU - Roehrich,Jens

AU - Lewis,Michael

AU - Squire,Brian

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - This paper explores governance mechanisms and the dynamic interplay of functional and dysfunctional behaviour, what we term ‘(dys)function’, in long-term inter-organizational relationships. Using two longitudinal cases of warship commissioning we argue although varying degrees of formalization is important when managing long-term relationships, organizations should learn not only to contract or build up trusting relations but consider both together as semi-coupled in terms of the impact such interplay has on performance. We discuss governance mechanisms as moving beyond notions of complementarity and substitution towards a more nuanced view where governance of inter-organizational relationships can be convergent or divergent. Our findings show that what is functional behaviour for one side of the dyad can be dysfunctional for the other party, also that relationships can exhibit functions and dysfunctions across forms of governance simultaneously. Our conclusions suggest that mismatches in governance mechanisms can be positive as well as negative, and it is the overall relationship atmosphere that determines the direction of the (dys)function. In building a context dependent understanding of governance we both summarise the (dys)functions associated with formal and informal governance mechanisms, and explore their impact on relationship exchange performance over time.

AB - This paper explores governance mechanisms and the dynamic interplay of functional and dysfunctional behaviour, what we term ‘(dys)function’, in long-term inter-organizational relationships. Using two longitudinal cases of warship commissioning we argue although varying degrees of formalization is important when managing long-term relationships, organizations should learn not only to contract or build up trusting relations but consider both together as semi-coupled in terms of the impact such interplay has on performance. We discuss governance mechanisms as moving beyond notions of complementarity and substitution towards a more nuanced view where governance of inter-organizational relationships can be convergent or divergent. Our findings show that what is functional behaviour for one side of the dyad can be dysfunctional for the other party, also that relationships can exhibit functions and dysfunctions across forms of governance simultaneously. Our conclusions suggest that mismatches in governance mechanisms can be positive as well as negative, and it is the overall relationship atmosphere that determines the direction of the (dys)function. In building a context dependent understanding of governance we both summarise the (dys)functions associated with formal and informal governance mechanisms, and explore their impact on relationship exchange performance over time.

U2 - 10.5465/ambpp.2017.10077abstract

DO - 10.5465/ambpp.2017.10077abstract

M3 - Article

VL - 2017

JO - Academy of Management Proceedings

T2 - Academy of Management Proceedings

JF - Academy of Management Proceedings

SN - 0065-0668

IS - 1

M1 - 10077

ER -