Conflict between genetic and phenotypic differentiation: The evolutionary history of a 'lost and rediscovered' shorebird

F E Rheindt, Tamas Szekely, S V Edwards, P L M Lee, T Burke, P R Kennerley, D N Bakewell, M Alrashidi, A Kosztolanyi, M A Weston, W T Liu, W P Lei, Y Shigeta, S Javed, S Zefania, C Kupper

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

30 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Understanding and resolving conflicts between phenotypic and genetic differentiation is central to evolutionary research. While phenotypically monomorphic species may exhibit deep genetic divergences, some morphologically distinct taxa lack notable genetic differentiation. Here we conduct a molecular investigation of an enigmatic shorebird with a convoluted taxonomic history, the White-faced Plover (Charadrius alexandrinus dealbatus), widely regarded as a subspecies of the Kentish Plover (C. alexandrinus). Described as distinct in 1863, its name was consistently misapplied in subsequent decades until taxonomic clarification ensued in 2008. Using a recently proposed test of species delimitation, we reconfirm the phenotypic distinctness of dealbatus. We then compare three mitochondrial and seven nuclear DNA markers among 278 samples of dealbatus and alexandrinus from across their breeding range and four other closely related plovers. We fail to find any population genetic differentiation between dealbatus and alexandrinus, whereas the other species are deeply diverged at the study loci. Kentish Plovers join a small but growing list of species for which low levels of genetic differentiation are accompanied by the presence of strong phenotypic divergence, suggesting that diagnostic phenotypic characters may be encoded by few genes that are difficult to detect. Alternatively, gene expression differences may be crucial in producing different phenotypes whereas neutral differentiation may be lagging behind.
Original languageEnglish
Article numbere26995
JournalPLoS ONE
Volume6
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Fingerprint

Population Genetics
Genetic Markers
Gene expression
Names
Breeding
Charadrius alexandrinus
Genes
History
Phenotype
Gene Expression
genetic variation
history
DNA
Charadriidae
Research
nuclear genome
population genetics
phenotype
gene expression
loci

Cite this

Conflict between genetic and phenotypic differentiation: The evolutionary history of a 'lost and rediscovered' shorebird. / Rheindt, F E; Szekely, Tamas; Edwards, S V; Lee, P L M; Burke, T; Kennerley, P R; Bakewell, D N; Alrashidi, M; Kosztolanyi, A; Weston, M A; Liu, W T; Lei, W P; Shigeta, Y; Javed, S; Zefania, S; Kupper, C.

In: PLoS ONE, Vol. 6, No. 11, e26995, 2011.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Rheindt, FE, Szekely, T, Edwards, SV, Lee, PLM, Burke, T, Kennerley, PR, Bakewell, DN, Alrashidi, M, Kosztolanyi, A, Weston, MA, Liu, WT, Lei, WP, Shigeta, Y, Javed, S, Zefania, S & Kupper, C 2011, 'Conflict between genetic and phenotypic differentiation: The evolutionary history of a 'lost and rediscovered' shorebird', PLoS ONE, vol. 6, no. 11, e26995. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0026995
Rheindt, F E ; Szekely, Tamas ; Edwards, S V ; Lee, P L M ; Burke, T ; Kennerley, P R ; Bakewell, D N ; Alrashidi, M ; Kosztolanyi, A ; Weston, M A ; Liu, W T ; Lei, W P ; Shigeta, Y ; Javed, S ; Zefania, S ; Kupper, C. / Conflict between genetic and phenotypic differentiation: The evolutionary history of a 'lost and rediscovered' shorebird. In: PLoS ONE. 2011 ; Vol. 6, No. 11.
@article{e72c28df190c494a9b00e3eb020b5b71,
title = "Conflict between genetic and phenotypic differentiation: The evolutionary history of a 'lost and rediscovered' shorebird",
abstract = "Understanding and resolving conflicts between phenotypic and genetic differentiation is central to evolutionary research. While phenotypically monomorphic species may exhibit deep genetic divergences, some morphologically distinct taxa lack notable genetic differentiation. Here we conduct a molecular investigation of an enigmatic shorebird with a convoluted taxonomic history, the White-faced Plover (Charadrius alexandrinus dealbatus), widely regarded as a subspecies of the Kentish Plover (C. alexandrinus). Described as distinct in 1863, its name was consistently misapplied in subsequent decades until taxonomic clarification ensued in 2008. Using a recently proposed test of species delimitation, we reconfirm the phenotypic distinctness of dealbatus. We then compare three mitochondrial and seven nuclear DNA markers among 278 samples of dealbatus and alexandrinus from across their breeding range and four other closely related plovers. We fail to find any population genetic differentiation between dealbatus and alexandrinus, whereas the other species are deeply diverged at the study loci. Kentish Plovers join a small but growing list of species for which low levels of genetic differentiation are accompanied by the presence of strong phenotypic divergence, suggesting that diagnostic phenotypic characters may be encoded by few genes that are difficult to detect. Alternatively, gene expression differences may be crucial in producing different phenotypes whereas neutral differentiation may be lagging behind.",
author = "Rheindt, {F E} and Tamas Szekely and Edwards, {S V} and Lee, {P L M} and T Burke and Kennerley, {P R} and Bakewell, {D N} and M Alrashidi and A Kosztolanyi and Weston, {M A} and Liu, {W T} and Lei, {W P} and Y Shigeta and S Javed and S Zefania and C Kupper",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0026995",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
journal = "PLoS ONE",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science (PLOS)",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Conflict between genetic and phenotypic differentiation: The evolutionary history of a 'lost and rediscovered' shorebird

AU - Rheindt, F E

AU - Szekely, Tamas

AU - Edwards, S V

AU - Lee, P L M

AU - Burke, T

AU - Kennerley, P R

AU - Bakewell, D N

AU - Alrashidi, M

AU - Kosztolanyi, A

AU - Weston, M A

AU - Liu, W T

AU - Lei, W P

AU - Shigeta, Y

AU - Javed, S

AU - Zefania, S

AU - Kupper, C

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Understanding and resolving conflicts between phenotypic and genetic differentiation is central to evolutionary research. While phenotypically monomorphic species may exhibit deep genetic divergences, some morphologically distinct taxa lack notable genetic differentiation. Here we conduct a molecular investigation of an enigmatic shorebird with a convoluted taxonomic history, the White-faced Plover (Charadrius alexandrinus dealbatus), widely regarded as a subspecies of the Kentish Plover (C. alexandrinus). Described as distinct in 1863, its name was consistently misapplied in subsequent decades until taxonomic clarification ensued in 2008. Using a recently proposed test of species delimitation, we reconfirm the phenotypic distinctness of dealbatus. We then compare three mitochondrial and seven nuclear DNA markers among 278 samples of dealbatus and alexandrinus from across their breeding range and four other closely related plovers. We fail to find any population genetic differentiation between dealbatus and alexandrinus, whereas the other species are deeply diverged at the study loci. Kentish Plovers join a small but growing list of species for which low levels of genetic differentiation are accompanied by the presence of strong phenotypic divergence, suggesting that diagnostic phenotypic characters may be encoded by few genes that are difficult to detect. Alternatively, gene expression differences may be crucial in producing different phenotypes whereas neutral differentiation may be lagging behind.

AB - Understanding and resolving conflicts between phenotypic and genetic differentiation is central to evolutionary research. While phenotypically monomorphic species may exhibit deep genetic divergences, some morphologically distinct taxa lack notable genetic differentiation. Here we conduct a molecular investigation of an enigmatic shorebird with a convoluted taxonomic history, the White-faced Plover (Charadrius alexandrinus dealbatus), widely regarded as a subspecies of the Kentish Plover (C. alexandrinus). Described as distinct in 1863, its name was consistently misapplied in subsequent decades until taxonomic clarification ensued in 2008. Using a recently proposed test of species delimitation, we reconfirm the phenotypic distinctness of dealbatus. We then compare three mitochondrial and seven nuclear DNA markers among 278 samples of dealbatus and alexandrinus from across their breeding range and four other closely related plovers. We fail to find any population genetic differentiation between dealbatus and alexandrinus, whereas the other species are deeply diverged at the study loci. Kentish Plovers join a small but growing list of species for which low levels of genetic differentiation are accompanied by the presence of strong phenotypic divergence, suggesting that diagnostic phenotypic characters may be encoded by few genes that are difficult to detect. Alternatively, gene expression differences may be crucial in producing different phenotypes whereas neutral differentiation may be lagging behind.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=80655139028&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0026995

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0026995

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0026995

M3 - Article

VL - 6

JO - PLoS ONE

JF - PLoS ONE

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 11

M1 - e26995

ER -