Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Acclaimed as a pinnacle of western civilization, a shining example of the Greeks’ genius and their concern for beauty, the Parthenon is a natural subject of inquiry into architectural proportion. We associate its aesthetic appeal with precision, technique and rigor as well as subtle artistic inflections that in its straining for perfection make it not mechanical but human, almost divine. Yet in spite of a plethora of analyses of the Parthenon there is little scholarly agreement about the ancient design procedures involved, or the unit of measure utilized. The primary purpose of this contribution is to highlight aspects of the design of the Parthenon of striking and surprising proportional coherence—surprising only in the sense that they have so far eluded detection. The modular method utilized (in effect an ancestor of the method Vitruvius bequeathed us a different variant) is compatible with each of the main metrical units previously advanced. Measurements and discrepancies are tabulated for the reader to evaluate.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationProportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration
EditorsMatthew A. Cohen, Maarten Delbeke
Place of PublicationLeiden
PublisherLeiden University Press
Chapter10
Pages199-231
Number of pages32
ISBN (Electronic)9789400602885
ISBN (Print)9789087282776
StatusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Proportion
Parthenon
Genius
Western Civilization
Vitruvius
Perfection
Aesthetics
Inflection
Ancestors
Reader

Cite this

Wilson Jones, M. (2018). Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’. In M. A. Cohen, & M. Delbeke (Eds.), Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration (pp. 199-231). Leiden: Leiden University Press.

Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’. / Wilson Jones, Mark.

Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration. ed. / Matthew A. Cohen; Maarten Delbeke. Leiden : Leiden University Press, 2018. p. 199-231.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Wilson Jones, M 2018, Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’. in MA Cohen & M Delbeke (eds), Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration. Leiden University Press, Leiden, pp. 199-231.
Wilson Jones M. Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’. In Cohen MA, Delbeke M, editors, Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration. Leiden: Leiden University Press. 2018. p. 199-231
Wilson Jones, Mark. / Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’. Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration. editor / Matthew A. Cohen ; Maarten Delbeke. Leiden : Leiden University Press, 2018. pp. 199-231
@inbook{02b107dde1c44fcc877b5a7ea4d4eb99,
title = "Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’",
abstract = "Acclaimed as a pinnacle of western civilization, a shining example of the Greeks’ genius and their concern for beauty, the Parthenon is a natural subject of inquiry into architectural proportion. We associate its aesthetic appeal with precision, technique and rigor as well as subtle artistic inflections that in its straining for perfection make it not mechanical but human, almost divine. Yet in spite of a plethora of analyses of the Parthenon there is little scholarly agreement about the ancient design procedures involved, or the unit of measure utilized. The primary purpose of this contribution is to highlight aspects of the design of the Parthenon of striking and surprising proportional coherence—surprising only in the sense that they have so far eluded detection. The modular method utilized (in effect an ancestor of the method Vitruvius bequeathed us a different variant) is compatible with each of the main metrical units previously advanced. Measurements and discrepancies are tabulated for the reader to evaluate.",
author = "{Wilson Jones}, Mark",
year = "2018",
language = "English",
isbn = "9789087282776",
pages = "199--231",
editor = "Cohen, {Matthew A. } and Maarten Delbeke",
booktitle = "Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration",
publisher = "Leiden University Press",
address = "Netherlands",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Approaches to Architectural Proportion and the ‘Poor old Parthenon’

AU - Wilson Jones, Mark

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Acclaimed as a pinnacle of western civilization, a shining example of the Greeks’ genius and their concern for beauty, the Parthenon is a natural subject of inquiry into architectural proportion. We associate its aesthetic appeal with precision, technique and rigor as well as subtle artistic inflections that in its straining for perfection make it not mechanical but human, almost divine. Yet in spite of a plethora of analyses of the Parthenon there is little scholarly agreement about the ancient design procedures involved, or the unit of measure utilized. The primary purpose of this contribution is to highlight aspects of the design of the Parthenon of striking and surprising proportional coherence—surprising only in the sense that they have so far eluded detection. The modular method utilized (in effect an ancestor of the method Vitruvius bequeathed us a different variant) is compatible with each of the main metrical units previously advanced. Measurements and discrepancies are tabulated for the reader to evaluate.

AB - Acclaimed as a pinnacle of western civilization, a shining example of the Greeks’ genius and their concern for beauty, the Parthenon is a natural subject of inquiry into architectural proportion. We associate its aesthetic appeal with precision, technique and rigor as well as subtle artistic inflections that in its straining for perfection make it not mechanical but human, almost divine. Yet in spite of a plethora of analyses of the Parthenon there is little scholarly agreement about the ancient design procedures involved, or the unit of measure utilized. The primary purpose of this contribution is to highlight aspects of the design of the Parthenon of striking and surprising proportional coherence—surprising only in the sense that they have so far eluded detection. The modular method utilized (in effect an ancestor of the method Vitruvius bequeathed us a different variant) is compatible with each of the main metrical units previously advanced. Measurements and discrepancies are tabulated for the reader to evaluate.

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9789087282776

SP - 199

EP - 231

BT - Proportional Systems in the History of Architecture. A Critical Reconsideration

A2 - Cohen, Matthew A.

A2 - Delbeke, Maarten

PB - Leiden University Press

CY - Leiden

ER -